I ordered an Andar the same day I ordered my Pro Max, and like many, I discounted the Finewoven cases offhand. Then I visited an Apple store, browsed over to one, touched it and liked it. It has a great feel (to me). So out the door I went with one, and I've picked up another color since.
For the past several years, I've had multiple cases, and I rotate them every few days. The Finewoven cases I have just went into the rotation. They still look great (maybe a slight magsafe ring indentation) and the suede like feel is unique.
They aren't for everyone, and that's fine. There's a lot of options in the case world. But they are a nice change of pace from my usual Andar leather cases.