Towards seeing both sides, and more
I'm pretty much loving it, too. Some of the UI elements remind me of Be OS
+1
BeOS on Mac hardware was an exceptionally classy experience. In retrospect I like to think of it as way ahead of its time.
There's
so much to love about Yosemite. The vast majority of it is refined and simply gorgeous. If I could ignore the one aspect that's a showstopper for me, I would. But I
enjoy Apple at its best, and ignorance of a problem is counterproductive. The best thing for a problem is to understand and if possible, address it
I prefer that iOS and OSX speaks the same design language.
I appreciate Apple's intention, but can not accept the parts that are built upon
a ridiculously twisted foundation. There's a long history of very high esteem for Apple's Human Interface Guidelines. For the 2014-10-16 edition to include technicially ridiculous guidance is somewhat shameful.
If Apple will correct those parts of the guidelines and make appropriate changes to the parts of apps that are regressive (or simply troublesome) as a result of that recent twisting then I'll be a very happy customer. In all truth, I'll never regain the confidence in Apple that has suffered as a result of the approach to developing Yosemite, but I
will be very happy and there'll be an end to so much noise from me.
really getting tiresome seeing all the threads after each update of OSX/iOS calling for a return to the stone age...
Exactly. It's nice to see some positive light about Yosemite after much bashing
A disklike for parts of 10.10 is not a call for a return to the stone age.
Hey, it could get "really tiresome seeing all the" dismissive exaggerations from people who disagree. An already frustrated person, or a group of already frustrated people, could feel somewhat "bashed" by exaggerated dismissal of detailed concerns, some of which have strong evidence as backup. If you want to bash Mavericks or a stone age graphical user interface to a computer, if you can find one ;-) go ahead. And if possible, make it something that's
not already written in this topic. But please, refrain from bashing people. It rarely has the desired outcome.
Personally: I don't feel bashed, I
prefer to keep a sense of humour