NVIDIA vs AMD FirePro
As I read here many times people often count on AMD
3rd party video cards for iMac 2011. In general, for 2011
iMac video cards from NVIDIA are recommended !
I only want to use AMD FirePro for 2009 to 2010 iMac
(no Sleep/wake issue). For anger most AMD cards are
needing the hotwire mod and except NVIDIA the AMD
cards are supported by Monterey and Ventura - so the
old platform (2009-2010) have more possibilities with
unsupported macOS versions.
Think to exchange from 2011 iMac (Big Sur + K2100M)
to 2013 Mac Pro (AMD Trashcan) plus Huawei MateView 28,
also this is after a period of time (unusual hardware design)
a dead rail...again !
Apfeltalk macOS Ventura + OCLP
OCLP + Ventura (german Version) - switch sound off if
you don't understand german - the youtube video is
understandable without explaination - OCLP GUI version
for Big Sur / Monterey / Ventura installation !
Technically the situation is more complex than you describe it here.
Each AMD card listed on the first post which is known to POST in the
iMac12,x will
run by far better than any NVIDIA card listed,
there is literally
no exception.
You get DRM support with most GCN1-3 card, additionally you get
4K HEVC and 4K H.264 support with all GCN4 cards. Finally you have
full Monterey support with all AMD cards. All cards support AirPlay
with Mojave and Catalina without any patching.
The problems come up
only if you decide to stop using the iMac
(sleep or shutdown and boot, later). This is funny, isn’t it.
The only disadvantage becomes obvious when you decide to not use
it for some time? Is this the way we judge technical tools, now?
NVIDIA iMac systems lost support with Monterey, do not support any
kind of DRM or VA (video acceleration), lack proper OpenCL support
on (patched) Monterey and the Xcode iOS simulator is broken, too.
If you decide to use the iMac as a tool running macOS to accomplish
a computational task the AMD equipped systems are superior. Apple
started 2013/2014 to build AMD based Macs and adopted macOS to
this AMD support until right now.
You if your intention is to run Windows only get a Pascal or Maxwell
card. If you plan is to run Mojave or Catalina only and need AirPlay
use a Kepler card. These are a different stories.
I agree to your final conclusion. But again, this is a first world view
where we have access to new shiny tools from the next Apple store
in exchange for some printed paper. Consume new electronics
regardless which effect it has to our environment….consume faster!