The Pelican Voyager is built extremely well and, imo, is just as protective as the defender would be...while looking better, again imo.
I've had it for 3 days now [ been thru the Apple leather case, Spigen Air Cushion, and Incipio Dual Pro ] and I honestly cannot find any major faults. Would've been nice if the power and volume buttons were a bit easier to depress, but I'm getting used to it.
I didn't bother using the supplied screen protector because I already have the Zagg tempered glass on the iphone.
The Apple leather case is just ...blah. Looks real sharp [ esp the midnight blue ] but I don't foresee it providing any drop protection.
The Spigen Air Cushion looks, and feels great! Only if it had sightly better front screen protection, I'd hang on to it !!
The Incipio Dual Pro, just like the Air Cushion, falls short on front screen protection, and the slightly slippery back didn't help either.
So far, the Pelican Voyager has been great. Great construction and, from what appears to be, amazing drop protection for back and front.
It nicely covers the glass edges that current tempered glass protectors don't. Makes me feel very confident using the Voyager.
The Voyager does add some bulk.. and makes my Note 3 feel almost feather weight now! But, it's a trade off I'm willing to accept to offset any damage from drops.
The holster and clip are rock solid, and I never felt the device would pop out and fall. At this point, it seems like $60 well spent!