I did the same exact thing you did, my iPhone 14 pro case was the greatest, after so many drops with the phone, yes the outer case was on it’s last leg but my phone still looked brand new. I was split between Bull and Nomad but ultimately I like the options Nomad offers on their cases, I’m loving it on the 16 pro max, plus it was one of the few ones that had a cut out for the camera button versus having it covered up on other cases.I just ordered a Nomad Horween modern leather case for my 16 pro max. I was going case-less, but decided I better get a case, mainly bc I don’t like the camera lenses exposed to any hard surfaces I may put the phone on. I had an apple leather case for my 14 PM and loved it - but bc they do not make them anymore, I did some research and Nomad seems to make some great quality leather cases - so I went with that.