OMG looks like my tweeting has been noticed. Gordon Kelly from Forbes has replied directly to my tweet and updated his article with also a statement from Samsung.
https://twitter.com/gordonkelly/status/580161012508323840
https://twitter.com/gordonkelly/status/580171063209959426
http://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonkelly/2015/03/23/samsung-galaxy-s6-edge-bloat/
His retraction / amendment was to basically link the mobile syrup response I sent him.
Samsung's response was the typical by the book (politician response) 'reviews/info were on pre-release software and issued whilst under embargo, we fail to comment' ....
Now here's another point that I am delighted proves something I raised in the HTC thread I mentioned in the last few days in regards to how so much stuff had been written about the M9 on pre-release software. I was challenged as to why HTC would allow reviewers to use a device on pre-release software. I mentioned they likely didn't have power of NDA whilst Samsung & Apple do.
SAMSUNG by their own official statement - has an embargo (basically a NDA) which I made the point of in that discussion that they generally (by their position as number 1 android OEM) have the power to enforce - whereas likes of HTC do not. What this also means is that there are definitely some 'information' about the device that is being concealed / held back from us. We will in turn find out once that embargo has been lifted if there really is an effort to debloat. Is Touchwiz still a ram whore. Or if I am right again and as I suspect under the hood Touchwiz is the same. (Which isn't an issue generally as long as the device has the power & ram to power on through it).
One thing is for certain, we are living in a world of marketing spin. Do not believe everything you read even if it's reposted on a dozen blogs. These sites need your traffic, their standards are poor in regards to checking facts and sources. They know people are looking or googling S6 / s6 Edge and their prime motivation for carrying these ill researched news posts is to drive traffic to their site. Put that into the back of your mind whenever you read good / bad or indifferent articles of a device pre-launch. And a general consensus (number of sites posting same thing) doesn't always equate to a truth. I can post at least 20 main news sites that have miss posted this 'all apps can be removed' story.
How many do you think will post retractions ? Very few because their aim wasn't about delivering reality it was about getting traffic. Which is evidently exactly what they achieved.
Furthermore most people went to these sites and read this misquoted articles; very few actually checked out the real XDA posters thread based on post count. The rabbid fanboy responses (comments section) in those news articles from people then declaring SAMSUNG were the new messiahs is stomach churning simply because blind faith seemed to win out over truth, research & objectivity.
Now let me make this clear. I want Samsung to have debloated their OS. I live in hope of it. But I also realise this is the company who has said this before, and never delivered. The company that has historically relied on power and ram to muscle through the detritus, and here we are with the most powerful CPU and Ram in a device. So despite Touchwiz being super fast and I believe it completely that this is so - I am still skeptical on the truth of the debloating. I suspect however that the muscle power of the S6 makes it mostly irrelevant as it does have the power and CPU, however I'm not willing to begin evangelising a second coming without proof. Something clearly even Samsung is hesitant to do given their 'official comment' when raised by a journalist who in turn only felt need to clarify after a certain MRU tackled them about it...
I will get my Emerald Green Edge but I won't be suckered into a world of make believe. My emerald green edge won't be from the land of OZ, and will not have magic powers bestowed upon it by some benevolent deity. It's a phone from Samsung and built on that companies past it will likely come with baggage - that I'm willing to accept due to the sexiness of the beast. Not because I want to indoctrinate myself into some brainwashed cult of mindless believers.
So please people... No more mindless believers. The phone will be great and so they should be as they're premium expensive. Let's just enjoy them foibles and all - don't put them in a holy shrine......