I am going to say it.
The Pixel 8 Pro is the best phone overall of the year.
If the absolute best in performance/gaming and largest screen is more important than the s23 ultra would be best phone of the year but you have some compromises to make in terms of weight and size.
So if the S23 ultra is the best in so many key areas then why do I say that the Pixel 8 Pro is the best phone of the year?
Design. The Pixel 8 Pro is about the most comfortable large bar phone I have ever used. Everything is rounded from the corners to the sides of the phone while the screen is flat. The aluminum frame is rounded which meets the rounded blasted glass back. So no matter where or how you hold the phone it feels comfortable in the hand.
I don't think we even consider these subtle design elements but the Pixel 8 Pro is all about details. It just feels like the Pixel wants to be held. The phone feels solid but light considering it's size. The camera bar is iconic and practical. Your hand naturally rests below it and it helps hold the phone in place.
Then there is the phone itself. The screen is just very comfortable on the eyes. The auto brightness feature actually works this time. I have tried auto brightness in every phone I have ever used and it always turns the screen down too low. The Pixel 8 Pro seems to adjust really quickly and dynamically and get it right most of the time. I don't find myself turning up the brightness. And in low light I am not blinded by too bright a screen. Combine this with a flat screen and high resolution and the OLED screen is just a pleasure to use.
The speakers are improved with a much better bass response than last year. I do wish in certain instances that the max volume was higher but overall the sound quality, depth and stereo separation is much better.
The cameras on the Pixel 8 Pro are great. Video stabilization is much better than before. Quick photos look great and with the Pro model you can adjust things to your liking.
Tensor G3 is finally, I can say it, a good chip. It may not be the class leader but it is no slouch this year. Efficiency, thermal throttling, thermal output, raw performance, battery life, have all been significantly improved. While I still think Google should have included vapor chamber cooling it is a huge improvement over last year.
Pixel UI and AI.
Beyond all of the improvements to the hardware this year Android 14 and Pixel unique AI features make the Pixel unlike any other phone. I am not going to list everything but if you have a Pixel you understand all of the benefits. Pixel UI is fluid, has thoughtful animations and has better customization than ever before. If you want to experience the best, cleanest Android experience then Pixel is it.