my experience so far is that updating from iOS 18.X IPSWs is bricking devices 100% of the time in a way that was not happening with any iOS 17.X IPSWs, so what do we call this issue and more importantly, does it still exist? I’m not sure what the argument is.
So far it has failed completely on iPhone 14 Pro Max, iPhone 16 Pro Max, and an iPad Air. This is of course several weeks ago, before iOS 18.1 RC was available. So it either is still doing it with these new IPSWs or not. We KNOW the issue existed, nobody has been able to definitively say whether or not it still does.
Windows users were able to manage their iPhones using Windows PCs since day 1 in 2007, or even earlier when it came to iPods, and it was always without issue. It shouldn’t be failing so catastrophically in this manner, and we definitely shouldn’t be handwaving the issue and covering it up when it does exist.