For me…As a owner of the first and 3rd gen 12.9 I'd say the 3rd gen offers much more.
1. USB C (the biggest deal for me)
2. 100gr lighter and more compact (another big deal)
3. pencil 2
4. promotion
5. compatibility with the magic keyboard
6. BT 5.0 (big deal for me as I can use airpods anywhere in the house, with no issue with range)
7. faster in some demanding web pages (like gmail, youtube etc.) Most people don't realize since they just use the apps. The first gen struggles sometimes
8. Neural engine, allows new features likes live text, spatial audio etc. (only from A12 and above)
I don't like faceid either and have disabled it, but many do...
1. I prefer lightning to USB-C. If Apple’s not going to have apps that use the transfer speed (FCPX, etc.), I’d rather have the ease of the iPhone connector.
2. More compact is better, agreed
3. Pencil 1 was superior for me, with wired charging (can’t use a grip on Pencil 2 and charge it reliably)
4. Old iPad Pros also have ProMotion
5. I don’t use Magic Keyboard (again, I would if powerful apps existed that would leverage a keyboard). If you do use it, then, yeah, you’d want the newer one
6. BT5 is nice, but my iPhone 11 Pro has it, and it still drops signal when I walk a room away.
7. Never seen my old 12.9 choke on a webpage, personally
8. Having a 2020, I’ve found I don’t use those things. Hell, the other day I tried to find a practical application for my fancy LiDar sensor, and didn’t really find much to do with it. ?
Just my experience, though.
EDIT: Apple is apparently presenting at NAB again, the first time since the FCPX rollout years ago. So maybe they’ll roll out Pro video apps that can actually leverage those processors. I think they’ll have to, or no one’s going to keep shelling out for “Pro” iPads…
Last edited: