Hey JoeyT:
I just downloaded and tried yummysoup on my macbook pro..
It's not bad, and much like connessoir. I wouldn't say it's better than MacGourmet.
Probably one of my favourite features of MacGourmet is how you can add recipes. Especially the dragging and dropping of recipe ingredients and directions right off a web page into macgourmet's recipe editor. so easy, it's a joke... divider lines, main ingredient tick boxes, etc.
have you downloaded and tried MacGourmet?
I'll fiddle with yummysoup a little more... it seems nice and stable compared to connessoir which seems to do strange things sometimes (mainly with recipe images).
YummySoups is quite 'minimalist'... it has no function to export the shopping list to say a PDA or iPod (handy) among other things. I'll definately give it points for it's full screen view. It's by far better than MacGourmey's full-screen view, which is a bit odd. I think
MacGourmet offers a 'wine notes' section with wine info, tasting notes, etc, handy. clippings, notes, and really fantastic 'find/search' features. I love 'cupboard search' which lets you punch in stuff u have in your cupboard and it pulls recipes to suit what you have...
If I could build my own app:
Interface of MacGourmet or YummySoup
Fullscreen view of YummySoup
Drag-in recipes from web of MacGourmet
Export to iPod feature of Connessoir
wine notes/tasting of MacGourmet
I'm sure I could think of more things..
I might sit down and hammer these main few apps, and do some pro's, con's, screen shots, maybe a little write up and throw it in this thread.
This is starting to become the ultimate 'kitchen mac' thread!
Definately keen for people to contribute value information if they desire!
James