Strange. I'm in the New York area (Brooklyn) and the last thing my tracking info shows is international shipping release. Did I miss the boat to Newark?
I wouldn't give up hope yet... it took a while for the shipping info to be updated. Check with flight tracking webtool the fed ex flights from indianapolis to EWR or possibly JFK. Yours might just go straight there... both flights to EWR were delayed by 1 hour, so I think we might have gotten really lucky in Newark area...
My original date btw was for Monday as well.... 2/4 FYI