Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
M1 MacBook Air black uniformity (red glow)
- Thread starter 0906742
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I know it is better since I had MBP 13" 2019 but I did not find screen so much better it was worth over 300 euros today. Bulk part price difference is minimal in reality.
Interesting since Notebookcheck review measured better bass in hearing range for Air. Pro did seem to go lower in lower HZ but it was already so much lower db it would not be possible to hear based on that. Anyway, not sure they are tuned different way in M1's but my MBP 13" 2019 sounded lot worse (very tinny) than MBA M1 (or MBA 2018 did).
I agree going 14" is wrong step and it will increase overall size, just like all other manufacturers their 14" model is larger than 13.3".
I guess that should be rather big step up with micro-led and price will be likely the same as current model. Also I think Pro gain finally faster CPU too, so those things alone makes me think MBP M1 in current form is more like a "placeholder" so that there is even one Pro model with Apple Silicon now until real Pro comes out.
So MBP M1 likely lose a lot of its value at that moment. MBA likely takes longer as usual to get Pro features fall in to them, so nothing real big coming there soon, I think.
Yeah, looks similar as all others here. You can also see this in the dark with black image with 100% brightness (on the right edge or upper corner)?
Im weighing up the pros and cons of the air v pro, two things come to mind for me. Battery screen on time and display. But since I have no experience in either for these models I’d appreciate feedback from those that do. Thanks.
Battery run time is obviously better in Pro due to practically over 20% higher battery capacity (I'm referring to actual capacity readings with Coconutbattery rather than spec's 50W vs 58,2W). For me that MBA M1 battery gives in actual harder use with display brightness at full minus 4-5 clicks about 10 hours operating time. I know some claim getting 15-20 hours and yes, that is possible too with letting it sit idle on desktop (or use some very basic apps like writing a book with a simple text editor) and have screen brightness around say below half to 1/3 or so, or something else with extremely low screen brightness. But still MBA M1 battery life is decent, around say 30% better than my MBP 13" 2019 was in the same use.
Display is also fine other than in situation described in this thread. In bright room it is just fine and very good even whites (no difference in tint between sides etc.) but that can vary a bit from unit to unit. In Pro you get much better black level and higher contrast ratio but it may or may not be even in brighter image (I had good panel in my MBP 2019 but not sure it is the same in M1, as based on photos here not quite as good as mine was). Anyway I would not pay the current premium for MBP M1 and I consider it kind of a "placeholder" for future Pro. I also like Air form factor more and appreciate more silent and solid keyboard and trackpad plus speaker sound quality.
Many thanks for the comment and feedback, appreciated it.
I think I want to spend the least amount of money on a current MacBook, because I won’t be doing any video editing or music production nor anything intensive. To be honest my previous MacBook Pro 16 i9 with 16GB and 1TB spec was wasted hardware due to me thinking I’d need all those extras. I used it primarily for Office, zoom calls etc.
I think this time around I’ll be sticking to base model with 512GB storage.
Sounds like MBA M1 is good enough easily. Only better screen in MBP but is it worth that much? I don't think so.
Disabling the text smoothing on the MBA solved something that is not bothering me on the MBP, maybe the coating is playing a role here. The whites on the MBP are also more uniform at least on my unit.
The general use of the keyboard and trackpad are good on both, but you are right, the MBA is something different, its slightly better on the MBA, it feels solid, the trackpad click feels more consistent also, it even have additional options like silent click available, so not everything on the MBP could actually be incrementally better.
The general use of the keyboard and trackpad are good on both, but you are right, the MBA is something different, its slightly better on the MBA, it feels solid, the trackpad click feels more consistent also, it even have additional options like silent click available, so not everything on the MBP could actually be incrementally better.
You sound like you’re only adding the better screen as to your comment, is it worth it $$. Don’t forget there’s a Touch bar, there is the additional battery time, Studio-quality three-mic array, 61W USB-C Power Adapter as opposed to the 30 watt for the air, and better speakers as well for that cost. Surprises me that some people accidentally or deliberately failed to add the additional hardware when they report this and the cost.
Last edited:
Well the difference depending on where I purchase it from is between 200 to 300$. I’m not trying to be one of those ( because I was and am) that says oh for another 200$ I can add this and then for just another $200 I can get that. It never ends 😂
I agree when some people find the Air better because of certain elements or nuances, $300 is not a big difference in my opinion, to give you some perspective, these machines on my country cost between $2700 for the 512mb Air and $3200 for the 512mb Pro.
I will say it again.
Base MBA is the best value for money...
The moment you start adding features to the base MBA (either RAM or HDD space) you already are in the MBP price range... and MBP starts making sense + it brings the number of (tiny) upgrades over the MBA
Base MBA is the best value for money...
The moment you start adding features to the base MBA (either RAM or HDD space) you already are in the MBP price range... and MBP starts making sense + it brings the number of (tiny) upgrades over the MBA
Last edited:
Well I needed 16 GB. I could only get it in a reasonable amount of time by ordering at an Apple store with the 1 TB update which I didn't need. An 8GB MBA wouldn't meet my needs. A 16 GB MBP with the same 1 TB required for purchasing in a reasonable time was $250 more than for the MBA and would be nearly the same computer for my use. Not a great value.
I can see it slightly when at 100% brightness while watching HDR movies, otherwise it hasn't really been an issue at all. I have a bigger issue with it being slightly warmer than my old 2016 15" MBP cuz I don't really know which is correct lol but still close enough that it probably won't matter for anything I'm doing.
Well, to me that is the only real difference between the two and considering the hard fact about panel price difference between the two is likely just some dollars.
I don't but I had that in my MBP 2019 and I never used it for anything. I actually noticed that I even preferred adjusting volume and screen brightness by hitting + and - icons instead of using the slider in TB.
So actually I prefer real keys in MBA. But surely if one has real actual use for TB (does anyone?) then surely it is worth maybe.
Absolutely if either of these is needed.
Again depending on use does it make difference or not.
My finding between my MBP 13" 2019 vs MBA M1 was that the charging time is actually shorter in my MBA when I charge them starting from my usual about 1/3 to 40% to 100%. It is that MBP never pulls full 61W from charger to charge the battery and it gradually drops it well below 30% when battery is above 50% or so, this makes charging wattage very similar above that level and due to smaller battery in MBA the time it takes actually goes like this. Sure that is useful if charging MBP while running something CPU demanding during that.
Again, I have never seen any test where they actually measured speakers with measuring gear Pro being better. Just read Notebookcheck reviews and you see MBA M1 got 95% for speakers while MBP M1 only 90% rating. Also measurements are shown in the same review.
These are useful reviews for all considering MBA M1 vs MBP M1 with actual measurements.
https://www.notebookcheck.net/Apple...o-gets-the-M1-performance-boost.510883.0.html
https://www.notebookcheck.net/Apple...le-M1-CPU-humbles-Intel-and-AMD.508057.0.html
I guess it is all about whether any of those are something you actually use or need.
Being hyper critical MBP slightly green left and pink right of screen. The only thing I do notice during day to day usage perhaps is the lower right side being dimmer or slightly pinker. Unless I look at it directly which minimizes it.
That's something I could not live with.
I was very happy to see MBA M1 has perfectly uniform white. Even better than my MBP 13" 2019 had.
all my lcd type panels are like this. Bearing in mind I have my brightness levels at 3 dots low.
WRONG.
Mines got a slight magenta tint on the right side and green on right side when viewing Safari at brightness below 50%
No they are not. I reject panels every time when they are like that. There are good panels too (except in 12 Pro obviously as that is probably the first lost battle for me after several exchanges
)My MBA M1 is even with white no matter what brightness setting.
Only thing with it is this red glow in mentioned conditions (which are not so normal use anyway but definitely it should not be like that).
Even my MBP was good, it was just slightly getting these blue spots, which is I guess something happening when they age (mine had nearly 70 charge cycles and over 1 year old to give some impression of machine age and usage).
Like if you open google.com? Or if you read this forum and there are white sides, you see it there too?
My is completely even tint.
Last edited:
Yes , Im very sensitive to these things and I base my judgment on day to day usage like Safari or Google white backgroundNo they are not. I reject panels every time when they are like that. There are good panels too (except in 12 Pro obviously as that is probably the first lost battle for me after several exchanges
My MBA M1 is even with white no matter what brightness setting.
Even my MBP was good, it was just slightly getting these blue spots, which is I guess something happening when they age (mine had nearly 70 charge cycles and over 1 year old to give some impression of machine age and usage).
Like if you open google.com? Or if you read this forum and there are white sides, you see it there too?
My is completely even tint.