I picked up a used Lotuff & Clegg English Briefcase in dark brown (Chocolate as they call it on the Lotuff site - Clegg and Lotuff split up a couple of years ago) off of the Styleforum.net classified section.
Anyway, here is the bag if you were to buy it new:
http://lotuffleather.com/collections/briefcases/products/english-leather-briefcase
Mine looks the same as the Chocolate color aside from the fact that on the inside, the branding says "Lotuff & Clegg" as opposed to just Lotuff.
In any event, I haven't made my final decision yet, as the bag just arrived today, but here are my initial thoughts:
WF Pros:
- More padding than the Booq, and given that the briefcase is not particularly padded, this may be one of the deciding factors.
- I like the flap and the extra padding if I am just carrying the laptop itself without the briefcase or another bag.
- Seems very well made and sturdy
WF Cons:
- Thicker front to back so takes up a bit more room in the briefcase
Booq Pros:
- Lighter and thinner (though this could also fall under cons since the lightness and thinness is due to essentially no padding whatsoever).
- Slides into and out of the bag slightly easier - though not that big of a deal as the WF is also easy to get in and out.
- Easier access if I just want to remove the laptop to use and leave the sleeve in the bag, since you basically just put your hand in the opening on the top, which splits the magnets and remove (versus the WF where you would need to fully open the flap to remove the actual laptop).
Booq Cons:
- No padding at all, so while a bit lighter and thinner than the WF, provides no additional padding/protection if the bag gets bumped/banged
- Seems a bit flimsier than the WF (though still seems like a quality product that won't fall apart or anything like that).
- Right now, the magnets seem to hold very well if you turn the sleeve upside down and even when you shake it - though if they were to fail while the sleeve happened to be upside down it could be catastrophic on the laptop. Whereas, the WF would have to have the velcro fail and then the flap open pretty much all the way (which presumably could happen). I'm not sure either is that likely but it seems like the magnets on the Booq might be a weaker link than the velcroed flap on the WF.
As of now, I think I'm leaning toward keeping the WF, as it seems like it would provide more protection from bangs and bumps than the Booq. But again, I haven't quite made a final decision at this point.
Ended up sending the Booq back today. I liked it, I just liked that the WF provided more protection while not being too bulky (though certainly bulkier than the Booq).