Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

runeapple

macrumors 6502a
Mar 5, 2010
663
123
Update - after several days usage I am typing far quieter, infact i'd say quieter then my previous model - so it's definitely just a matter of retraining yourself when typing - also i'm typing faster and with better accuracy.

Haven't noticed any red graphics issues SO FAR since stopping using fullscreen apps.

Overall loving the machine, it seems to be handling everything i'm throwing at it so far :)
 

Tim7

macrumors 6502
Dec 18, 2009
397
119
Gravesend, Kent, UK
What an absolutely amazing machine this is. I have a base 13" touchbar, and it's just incredible. The engineering alone just to fit everything in and still be this good is superb. The whole product just screams quality from the moment you start using it. It's genuinely a pleasure to use.

Looking forward to doing some work stuff tomorrow and using Word and Excel. Will be even better when they are updated for touchbar support too.

I only play 1 game which is Football Manager, and it runs that amazingly smoothly and fast at medium graphics which is great. On my old late 2013 retina MacBook Pro it was on low graphics and even then was very jumpy.

Well done, Apple!
 

danieleilertsen

macrumors regular
Jun 1, 2016
188
55
Oslo, Norway
I am having many problems with my macbook pro 15 with touchbar (Best spec).

1. Everytime I "log on" the display flickers. Found out it goes away if I turn off filevault.

2. When watching a movie, connected to a tv via hdmi adapter I got from apple, the picture goes away (it turns completely black on the tv) every couple of minutes. The black screen lasts about a half a second before showing the normal movie picture thats running. Tried different files. Happens every time.

3. The battery life is crazy short. Been using safari, on 100 prosent battery from start, and now 20 minutes later we are down to 73 %. 2 hours and 55 minutes left. Come on!

4. When I try to move a file in finder the track pad is not able to move it. Its like the track pad doesn't recognize my left finger when i am holdning it down.

Tried reinstalling sierra.
 

matteomanfredi

macrumors regular
Original poster
Nov 10, 2016
172
89
Italy
I feel like I have to clear up some stuff about FileVault since there seems to be a lot of fretting in this thread about things that aren't problems.

FileVault encrypts your entire boot disk, which means that the system can't actually boot from it until it can unlock it with a password. So, when you first boot up your Mac with FileVault enabled, what you're seeing isn't actually macOS, it's the Mac's EFI firmware with a copy of your desktop picture and the user list. It'll take your password, and if it's valid, will unlock your disk then start booting macOS.

Because you're not interacting with macOS, it'll look and feel subtly different than the real thing. And, as far as I'm aware, the firmware doesn't use the GPU to accelerate its UI (the firmware is really small and very limited in what it can do), so it'll feel slower.

So:

  1. The progress bar you see after entering your password with FileVault is the real macOS booting — it's completely normal! Once macOS has booted, the firmware hands over the username and password you entered to macOS so it can log you in.

  2. The little flicker you see is the firmware handing over control of the display to macOS — also completely normal, though less smooth than my old MacBook. Perhaps a future firmware update will fix it.

The boot process being different with FileVault is completely expected because the computer somehow needs to get a password from you to unlock the disk before macOS can boot. Apple tries to mask this (rather complex) handover procedure by pretending you're looking at a normal login screen, which it achieves pretty well considering the limitations of running in firmware.

I have FileVault enabled on my Touch Bar MBP and it behaves in the ways I described above — it's perfectly fine!
The only thing I noticed is a extreme drop in write performances, which is to be expected, but wasn't expecting a half!
[doublepost=1480241194][/doublepost]
I am having many problems with my macbook pro 15 with touchbar (Best spec).

1. Everytime I "log on" the display flickers. Found out it goes away if I turn off filevault.

2. When watching a movie, connected to a tv via hdmi adapter I got from apple, the picture goes away (it turns completely black on the tv) every couple of minutes. The black screen lasts about a half a second before showing the normal movie picture thats running. Tried different files. Happens every time.

3. The battery life is crazy short. Been using safari, on 100 prosent battery from start, and now 20 minutes later we are down to 73 %. 2 hours and 55 minutes left. Come on!

4. When I try to move a file in finder the track pad is not able to move it. Its like the track pad doesn't recognize my left finger when i am holdning it down.

Tried reinstalling sierra.
For point 1. go back and read the post I quoted. For the battery are you sure it's not something else in the background?
 
Last edited:

danieleilertsen

macrumors regular
Jun 1, 2016
188
55
Oslo, Norway
The only thing I noticed is a extreme drop in write performances, which is to be expected, but wasn't expecting a half!
[doublepost=1480241194][/doublepost]
For point 1. go back and read the post I quoted. For the battery are you sure it's not something else in the background?

What do you mean with the post you quoted?

Yes there is nothing else other then safari running. What do you think about 2 and 3?
 

Grolubao

macrumors 68000
Dec 23, 2008
1,579
583
London, UK
Battery life sucks and my spacebar key is very spongy with no travel at all. I'm swapping it so another month waiting. Well, better get back to the previous thread then :(
 

technoholic

macrumors 6502a
Mar 20, 2016
629
305
Battery life sucks and my spacebar key is very spongy with no travel at all. I'm swapping it so another month waiting. Well, better get back to the previous thread then :(
I tested every new MacBook in 2 London stores yesterday. All space bars are the same
 

Tamagotchi

macrumors 6502
Jun 13, 2013
369
412
I am having many problems with my macbook pro 15 with touchbar (Best spec).

1. Everytime I "log on" the display flickers. Found out it goes away if I turn off filevault.

2. When watching a movie, connected to a tv via hdmi adapter I got from apple, the picture goes away (it turns completely black on the tv) every couple of minutes. The black screen lasts about a half a second before showing the normal movie picture thats running. Tried different files. Happens every time.

3. The battery life is crazy short. Been using safari, on 100 prosent battery from start, and now 20 minutes later we are down to 73 %. 2 hours and 55 minutes left. Come on!

4. When I try to move a file in finder the track pad is not able to move it. Its like the track pad doesn't recognize my left finger when i am holdning it down.

Tried reinstalling sierra.

All those problems are very weird. Have you tried talking to someone from Apple? If you are within the 15 day period (I think you are) you can change it for a new one at Apple, or even give it back with a full refund.
 

92elliot

macrumors member
Nov 16, 2016
36
6
London
Do you guys shutdown your Macs all the time or just close the lid?

The only thing i miss (apart from magsafe) i used to shutdown from the power button when you would get the sleep, restart, shutdown menu but not the case with the new machine looks like you have to go via the apple log in the top left....unless i am missing a preference to enable that old behaviour?
 

Daventry

macrumors regular
Sep 23, 2011
106
63
I haven't had any graphics card issues other than the screen glitch upon logging in when having FileVault on.

I'm loving it so far, the space grey colour is amazing!

Mine is 15" and feels via try light when compared to my old 2010 15" MBP.

I like the TouchBar - find it useful when switching between tabs in Safari and also the TouchSwitcher app.

Touch ID is awesome!
 

92elliot

macrumors member
Nov 16, 2016
36
6
London
i have not found many instances in using touch-id yet on the machine. Hopefully will come into play more when apple pay becomes more accepted as an online payment method.
 

Brookzy

macrumors 601
May 30, 2010
4,985
5,577
UK
Poll: am I mad for letting this little scuff (that I didn't cause) bother me? :p

FullSizeRender (1).jpg
 

Brookzy

macrumors 601
May 30, 2010
4,985
5,577
UK
No - send it back, get a new. You paid premium for this product. So needs to be right.
Hmm, it isn't ideal. But I've had it since Wednesday and have only just discovered it - I will probably have a hard time convincing them it wasn't caused by me. I think I'll stick with it. No guarantees another one won't have an issue too.
 

Grolubao

macrumors 68000
Dec 23, 2008
1,579
583
London, UK
Guys, don't want to be a pain in the arse with my problem, but would be great to know if you too feel that the spacebar key is a bit weird and doesn't feel like the other keys. Thanks
 

Jaekae

macrumors 6502a
Dec 4, 2012
712
441
Guys, don't want to be a pain in the arse with my problem, but would be great to know if you too feel that the spacebar key is a bit weird and doesn't feel like the other keys. Thanks

could be because its the only key thats alot bigger than the rest :)
 

matteomanfredi

macrumors regular
Original poster
Nov 10, 2016
172
89
Italy
What do you mean with the post you quoted?

Yes there is nothing else other then safari running. What do you think about 2 and 3?
The post in the first part of my original reply where there is an explanation of what happens in the login screen if you use FileVault.

There could be something else, like Spotlight, running in the background.

For point 2 I guess it could be a faulty adapter or cable. Check, if possible with another cable or try another computer without that adapter.

For point 4 (I assume you intended this) it could be a software bug or a problem with the touchpad, contact Apple or, better, go into an Apple Store.
 

nbizzle

macrumors newbie
Nov 21, 2016
4
1
Hey guys,
is someone having problems mounting an external SSD on some of the ports? I'm using a Samsung T3, it only mounts on the lower left hand side port and on the upper right hand side one.
I don't get it...
I read somewhere that not all of the ports can deliver high speed TB3, but still they all should mount the SSD, shouldn't they?
SMC & NVRAM reset didn't help...
 

npreq

macrumors member
Nov 23, 2016
81
37
I feel like I have to clear up some stuff about FileVault since there seems to be a lot of fretting in this thread about things that aren't problems.

FileVault encrypts your entire boot disk, which means that the system can't actually boot from it until it can unlock it with a password. So, when you first boot up your Mac with FileVault enabled, what you're seeing isn't actually macOS, it's the Mac's EFI firmware with a copy of your desktop picture and the user list. It'll take your password, and if it's valid, will unlock your disk then start booting macOS.

Because you're not interacting with macOS, it'll look and feel subtly different than the real thing. And, as far as I'm aware, the firmware doesn't use the GPU to accelerate its UI (the firmware is really small and very limited in what it can do), so it'll feel slower.

So:

  1. The progress bar you see after entering your password with FileVault is the real macOS booting — it's completely normal! Once macOS has booted, the firmware hands over the username and password you entered to macOS so it can log you in.

  2. The little flicker you see is the firmware handing over control of the display to macOS — also completely normal, though less smooth than my old MacBook. Perhaps a future firmware update will fix it.

The boot process being different with FileVault is completely expected because the computer somehow needs to get a password from you to unlock the disk before macOS can boot. Apple tries to mask this (rather complex) handover procedure by pretending you're looking at a normal login screen, which it achieves pretty well considering the limitations of running in firmware.

I have FileVault enabled on my Touch Bar MBP and it behaves in the ways I described above — it's perfectly fine!

You're almost right. It's not the EFI firmware, it's a tiny boot partition
3: Apple_Boot Boot OS X 134.2 MB disk0s3

I'm tempted to mount it and find out what makes it tick, but not right now, I need to sleep >.>
 

Jaekae

macrumors 6502a
Dec 4, 2012
712
441
Hmm, it isn't ideal. But I've had it since Wednesday and have only just discovered it - I will probably have a hard time convincing them it wasn't caused by me. I think I'll stick with it. No guarantees another one won't have an issue too.

Overtime you probably make some of those dings on your own, not worth waiting for a new one in my opinion
[doublepost=1480311723][/doublepost]
Hey guys,
is someone having problems mounting an external SSD on some of the ports? I'm using a Samsung T3, it only mounts on the lower left hand side port and on the upper right hand side one.
I don't get it...
I read somewhere that not all of the ports can deliver high speed TB3, but still they all should mount the SSD, shouldn't they?
SMC & NVRAM reset didn't help...

The samsung T3 is usb3,0 speed, so it should work fine on all ports unless the ports are defective
 
  • Like
Reactions: karbim
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.