Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
That reminds me of a question i have for the group. So far, I've managed to upgrade all of my older Macs to Catalina (iMac 8,1, Macbook 5,1, Mac Mini 4,1) except my two Mac Pro 3,1s. One of them (my desktop production machine) has the APFS boot ROM patch from dosdude1. The other one (my media server) does not. So I see there is a difference in the installation process as stated above.

But my question is this: what is now the best practice for upgrading the Mac 3,1 to APFS booting? Do we still do the APFS ROM patcher or is it considered unnecessary (and maybe a little dangerous) with the software only solution nowe available for Catalina?
You can do 2 different installs from the same patcher if you chose "install to this machine". Open the patcher and before you do anything else (for the cMP3.1with APFS ROM) deselect the APFS option in the menu drop down (under options). Once you have done this continue with the install. The patcher will make temporary installer and then install to the drive of your choice. For the other machine just leave the APFS option ticked and you will get the APFS software patch installed. You will know you have this as there will be some scrolling text during startup.
Updating the ROM does have some risk but most of us on here have found the ROM patch works well for the cMP3.1. The choice is yours!
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
Installed it on a MacBookPro8,2 late 2011 15. Sleep/Wake/Brightness are working, but I'm not able to load the AMDRadeonX3000.kext post-boot, in an attempt to get better thermal condition.

The late 2011 MacBook Pro as a problem with the GPU and to bypass it, I used this solution in High Sierra : https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/267581/gpu-problem-boot-hangs-on-grey-screen/295805#295805

some discussions about it here : https://forums.macrumors.com/thread...ed-gpu-efi-variable-fix.2037591/post-27852775

and here:


It seems that the AMDRadeonX3000.kext included in the legacy video patch is "broken" ? Any idea about that?
I can confirm that the kext provided by dosdude1 in his Catalina installer works fine.

I had the same problem, so I went digging a little to find Catalina has two extensions folders now. I'm not sure if one is just a remnant from the previous installs (upgraded from Mojave) or what, but because Catalina now has two partition (a read only system partition and a read/write data partition), I had to do a somewhat inconvenient workaround to get the loginhook to work again.

First, go to finder and check /System/Library/Extensions/ to check to see if the AMDRadeonX3000.kext is present there. That is in the read only partition, so if it's there, you're going to have to create the Extensions-off folder, copy the AMDRadeonX3000.kext from Extensions to Extension-off and then delete the original from the regular Extensions directory. I had to do this using the High Sierra partition I kept for just in case something on these non supported systems ever messed up because doing it in single user mode as those instructions said just came up with a permission denied error.

Once I moved the kext, I did the usual boot in single user mode, mounted the drive (/sbin/mount -uw /) and just touched the Extensions directory. My temps went from 80+ degrees to ~65 degrees idle.

As for the force-iGPU-boot.sh file, I just copied that to the Catalina root directory from High Sierra at the same time as I moved the kext. So far, so good. The system has been pretty rock solid so far, but I'm afraid many apps are going to start requiring Metal or having blank elements like the latest release of FCPX. It just has a blank preview screen when editing which is pretty important for a video editor.

Now I have two Extensions directories out of fear of the system actually needing the one in /Library/Exentions/, but that hasn't affected system performance or given any errors so far.

I hope that helps!

Edit: Sorry, I just wanted to clarify something. The loginhook from those instructions points to /System/Library/Extensions-off/ in order to load the AMDRadeonX3000.kext, but when I upgraded from Mojave, the Extensions-off folder I had created was moved to /Library/Extensions-off/ which is why it wasn't working. The new location of /System/Library/Extensions/ is on the read only partition while the /Library/Extensions/ folder is in the Catalina-Data read/write partition. You should be able to re-write the loginhook to just point to the new directory, but I didn't. Come to think of it, that might have been easier.
 
Last edited:
Might be something you could ask Dosdude1
[automerge]1570681321[/automerge]

Certain AMD GPU's didn't even work in Mojave like 4,5,6xxx series where Nvidia GPU's do but that could change as Apple and Nvidia are not getting along

But why does like the Radeon 2600 from the imac 2008 work in mojave but the radeon 6950M from the 2011 imac doesnt? isn’t the 2600 older?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
BlueSky 1.4.4 has been released which includes support for the public release of macOS 10.15 Catalina and improved version checking. This should solve all those incompatibility issues. For those who did not see on the Discord server, the previous versions have been removed and 1.4.4 doesn't support the 10.15 betas. You can download it here.

Hi,

just installed Cat on my MBP2010 yesterday. Today the BlueSky Patch: everything worked perfectly fine.
Only one thing... I have Sublime Text installed and here (only here, didn't find another app), there is still a small light mode glitch: the navigation bar in the "Save As" windows is still dark.
As another funny fact: when making a screenshot, it looks fine. So I took a picture with my phone :) IMG_4082.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
it didn't work for me , still have the check failed issue :

+ Checked system environment.
+ Root permissions check passed.
+ Resources check passed.
/ What operation would you like to run?
/ Input an operation number.
/ 1 - Patch installer
/ 2 - Patch update
/ 1
/ What installer would you like to use?
/ Input an installer path.
/ /Users/zaksag/Downloads/Install\ macOS\ Catalina.app
+ Checked installer structure.
+ Mounted installer disk images.
+ Checked installer version.
> Checking installer support.
- Installer support check failed.
/ Run this tool with a supported installer.

-

the BlueSky work very well btw👌
Maybe your install is corrupt. It works for me with the latest version of Catalina.
 
I installed Catalina 2 Days ago on a Mac Mini5,1 (Mid 2011) and BlueSky 1.1.4 today.

Why do I have the Feedback Assistant if the version is not beta (build 19A583)?
Also, Auto Dark Mode doesn't work properly (missing metal gpu?)

The rest is running smoothly and after I threw an SSD in the computer it has become faster than I expected.
It's time to upgrade to 8 GB RAM now :)

Thanks a lot for your effort guys, it's nice to see a 9 year old computer still rocking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
Maybe your install is corrupt. It works for me with the latest version of Catalina.
it happened several times while creating the installer drive using the macOS patcher guide.
i got the same error message with mojave then it worked once you upgrade the patcher release.
i will wait for the final release hoping thing will be sorted out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
yeah but why? that’s what i’m trying to understand.. Why does the 6xxx not have acceleration but the 4*** series does?
The 6xxx doesn't have the SSE 4.1 instructions the helps with acceleration
[automerge]1570727830[/automerge]
it happened several times while creating the installer drive using the macOS patcher guide.
i got the same error message with mojave then it worked once you upgrade the patcher release.
i will wait for the final release hoping thing will be sorted out.
Are you using the latest version of the macOS Catalina Patcher 1.1.7
 
  • Like
Reactions: zaksag
Hi,

just installed Cat on my MBP2010 yesterday. Today the BlueSky Patch: everything worked perfectly fine.
Only one thing... I have Sublime Text installed and here (only here, didn't find another app), there is still a small light mode glitch: the navigation bar in the "Save As" windows is still dark.
As another funny fact: when making a screenshot, it looks fine. So I took a picture with my phone :)View attachment 868331
Pretty sure that's just because you have a dark window behind it...
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
Confirming that macOS Catalina Patcher 1.1.7 cannot make APFS encrypted work even with BootROM patched too.

Installed on clear APFS new partition
Enabled FileVault. Waited until completion.
Restart machine.
Boot in the partition, Catalina image salutes asking for password... enter the password and system reboots!

Tries 3 times, same issue.

Also tried to install on an pre-formatted APFS encrypted and same issue

Has anybody been able to make FileVault work and successfully boot in the encrypted ?

Without this I won't "upgrade" to Catalina...
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
Confirming that macOS Catalina Patcher 1.1.7 cannot make APFS encrypted work even with BootROM patched too.

Installed on clear APFS new partition
Enabled FileVault. Waited until completion.
Restart machine.
Boot in the partition, Catalina image salutes asking for password... enter the password and system reboots!

Tries 3 times, same issue.

Also tried to install on an pre-formatted APFS encrypted and same issue

Has anybody been able to make FileVault work and successfully boot in the encrypted ?

Without this I won't "upgrade" to Catalina...
I've been looking into it, but haven't found the cause at this point.
 
Hello! Successfully used @dosdude1 patch and upgraded my MacBook Pro mid 2009 to beta (19A573) but now cannot upgrade to final release. Patcher still downloading same version (installer 15.0.31) and software update doesn’t work too. Is there solution? or maybe a way to download latest version without App Store?

Same problem here and no solution:(
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
@Howard Ellacott Hi. Looks like we have the same GPU, and I am having issues with my machine, trying to watch videos and getting high CPU usage.

Can you please re-test and confirm if hardware acceleration is working fine on your system? Thank you very much for your time and attention.
Watching videos etc is fine, not high CPU usage. Mine is a 13 so doesn’t have a dedicated GPU, which could be the issue on yours?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
as there have been major changes from macOS Mojave to Catalina if GDC Beast uses any 32 bit code it will not work in Catalina macOS Mojave is the last OS that still supports 32 bit apps
GDC Beast is just a piece of hardware, no software involved. Anyway, I've just installed Mojave, and the result is the same: the card is not recognized. Same as with Catalina, if I DON'T apply the legacy Video card patch, it's just as if the card wasn't there. If I apply it, System Report tells me that there's an AMD GPU in the PCIe slot, but it doesn't recognize the model (it's an RX 560) and it says that there's no Kext loaded.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
Hi, wondering if anyone can offer some help. Using dosdude1's patcher I upgraded my MacPro 4,1 to Catalina. Previously my Apple Watch series 3 unlocked my Mac, with Mojave installed. Since the upgrade this doesn't appear to be working. Is this expected or has anyone had this problem and resolved it? I've tried various sequences of restarts on all devices and toggling Bluetooth/Wi-Fi to try and spark it into life but without success.

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

Thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
Earlier today I installed Catalina on my Mac. This Mac uses a Huawei USB Internet Dongle to connect.
Needless to say the Mobile Broadband app it uses is 32bit, so I was not expecting it to connect to the internet once Catalina was up and running, however I was surprised to see that it did connect, and it downloaded the Night Shift Patch and Broadcom patch, and also e-mails.
That didn't last long though, I had to boot back to an earlier macOS, and then switched back to Catalina, and since then it will not connect, Network reports the dongle is not connected.
So I was wondering if anyone knows of a USB Mobile Broadband unlocked dongle that definitely has a 64bit app built in.

Thanks in advance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimothyR734
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.