I've perused through a handful of Apple Watch reviews today and most (even renowned Apple fanboys) seem to be fairly critical of quite a few aspects--most commonly not enough notification control, not intuitive, a little laggy (when the watch face appears) or just simply a bit slow. Conversely, most also claim it to be the best smart watch available so, not really sure what that says about either the Apple Watch or its Android Wear counterparts---probably that nothing on the market now is really game changing at this point.
I would agree with this. I actually didn't even know Apple Watch reviews were out when I made my post. I've been scanning some myself where time allows throughout the day. Mostly average reviews, but also, as you say, rather favorable too at the same time. I still think there is some bias and favoritism going on. They are still rather forgiving.
For example, where Samsung or other Android Wear OEMs' watches are tied to a Samsung/Android device, that seemed like a huge knock in reviews. The Watch is tied to the iPhone, but that is seen as more of a natural "extension" of the iPhone, and the question is whether one wants that extension or not. When phrased this way, it's not so much a negative, but more of a lifestyle choice of the user.
I'm also not seeing a lot of reviews factoring in the price very much, and leaving it more to the reader as an option; that it's up to them to sort that all out and weigh whether it's worth the price or not. Whereas, if I recall correctly, there were knocks made against Samsung and other Android Wear OEMs for their "expensive" smartwatches. I think the prices of the Watch are pretty insane, especially some of the higher tier ones (not even talking about the Watch Edition!). And to me, it's insane that it's still lacking GPS.
All in all, considering the "decent' reviews, I guess this is as honest as these guys will get when it comes to an Apple review -- say it's better than Android and other competitors, but also admit that people may not need it and it's up to them to decide. That's basically what I've taken away.
I believe the things in this article (
The Apple Media Distortion Field:
https://medium.com/krautreporter-stories/the-apple-media-distortion-field-644e9e7b8666). Given that, I guess this is the best we'll get.
EDIT: For the record, I don't think any current smartwatch is worth the price. For fitness, I have my Garmin Forerunner 220 that has GPS, AMAZING battery life especially when the GPS is turned off, and is reliable and accurate at tracking my pace, distance, and stats. And 100% waterproof.