Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Music - Missing Features, Bugs, Issues & Troubleshooting
- Thread starter ErikGrim
- WikiPost WikiPost
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
- Status
Traverse
macrumors 604
My biggest issue with the Music app really is all the little annoying bugs that keep popping up and require you to quit the app to get it back to normal. I noticed these in Catalina and they're not fixed in Big Sur. Two of these include the following if I keep the Music app open for long periods of time or give it moderate use:
My biggest feature request as of now would be:
- Eventually double-clicking just stops working. I can double click on a song all I want, but it won't play unless I click the small "play" arrow to the left.
- Connection to Music just breaks. Either "Listen Now" just spins or clicking "Show in Apple Music" on an album just flashes and loads nothing.
My biggest feature request as of now would be:
- Allow us to set the View All or View Only Downloaded by view. I want my Music playlist to show my cloud music, but the album view to only show my downloaded music.
- Allow us to put Music playlists into a folder.
- Better optimization of space. Using Music.app in a relatively large window results in a lot of wasted space (why is album view restricted to a set number per row?)
- Allow smart playlists to reference other smart playlists in iCloud Music Library (not Music.app related, but had to throw it in).
RednBlue
macrumors regular
- Better optimization of space. Using Music.app in a relatively large window results in a lot of wasted space (why is album view restricted to a set number per row?)
Music has yet again forced me back on iTunes and the difference is night and day: The speed, the responsiveness, the compactness of the UI, the lack of bugs! Every single element is so much better. It launches and is operational in no time (which one would think you ought to expect on a 2020 iMac).
The only thing it appears to be incompatible with are HomePods as default speakers on AppleTV :/
The only thing it appears to be incompatible with are HomePods as default speakers on AppleTV :/
Last edited:
srbNYC
macrumors 68020
I have an extensive library from ripped CDs, and attempting the shift back to iTunes scares me!
RednBlue
macrumors regular
I previously had made two attempts to go back to iTunes via the Retroactive app, both of which went wrong - without any damage to my Music library although some cover art went missing; however following ErikGrim's post yesterday I tried again and it all went in faultlessly...no lost songs; no lost cover art, just a few artist images taking their time to refresh, which is normal in my experience.
As Erik says it's so much more responsive and has the advantage of scaleable cover art - 9 across in full screen mode on my 24inch Dell monitor.
I'm still using Music to sync with my iPhone, but for day-to-day use iTunes is easily my preference.
As Erik says it's so much more responsive and has the advantage of scaleable cover art - 9 across in full screen mode on my 24inch Dell monitor.
I'm still using Music to sync with my iPhone, but for day-to-day use iTunes is easily my preference.
Not going to lie, losing 6 months of organising hasn't been painless. Especially since my library was split across two harddrives. But it'll all be worth it not having to deal with the shambles that "Music" has become. Just the endless beachballs alone on a $5000 computer! What an ignominious end to iTunes. 🙁
It likely won't last forever. There might be future features like HomePods as default speakers for Apple TV that won't work (ex. new combined HomePod / AppleTV coming). And frankly Music is an embarrassment for Apple, especially as a front end to their flagship service. It needs to be fixed (or at this stage, nuked and replaced).
derekww
macrumors member
The experience of upgrading to an M1 Mac running Big Sur has been overwhelmingly positive in all aspects from hardware to software, except for Music! It's the only part of my new Mac experience that is negative. In my previous Mac launching iTunes means having beautiful classical music coming out of my sound system. Now I dread clicking anything in Music, worrying I would lose album artwork, lose or corrupt files, etc. Apple really took the pleasure of music listening away. I know this post is not constructive but I just have to rant.
funnysharks
macrumors member
derekww
macrumors member
Me too, I also cannot drag and drop to change the order of Playing Next. Current version of Big Sur (11.2.3).
Airsculpture
macrumors 6502
I've now done 3 months back on iTunes on Big Sur and cannot be happier. I only lasted a few days with Music before moving back.
Thank heaven for Retroactive 1.9
Thank heaven for Retroactive 1.9
cubbie5150
macrumors 6502a
Man, pretty much nothing but issues with Music since first moving to Big Sur @ 11.2's release.
I even nuked my old iTunes library (music files & library stored on external HD) and reimported into Music under a new "Music" folder on my external HD. I mostly used iTunes (and Music) to manage my library because 99% of my music listening is done on portable devices. Anyway, I've discovered that many files are "not located" (or whatever)...I have to search for them and manually re-add them to the library database. Man, what a waste of time.
I even nuked my old iTunes library (music files & library stored on external HD) and reimported into Music under a new "Music" folder on my external HD. I mostly used iTunes (and Music) to manage my library because 99% of my music listening is done on portable devices. Anyway, I've discovered that many files are "not located" (or whatever)...I have to search for them and manually re-add them to the library database. Man, what a waste of time.
srbNYC
macrumors 68020
Just looked through the Github discussions about Retroactive, and I'm now definitely too scared to try it.
Airsculpture
macrumors 6502
I’ve installed both on Catalina and Big Sur and not had one single issue or lost file
Issues generally are with M1 machines not Intel
Issues generally are with M1 machines not Intel
Airsculpture
macrumors 6502
DICK_CHENEY
macrumors member
Noticed earlier that the equalizer settings sometimes aren't being retained even after just pausing a track. The drop down menu still shows the same EQ setting in place, but it's no longer actually active. Switching to another EQ setting and then switching back to the EQ setting I actually want brings it back.
At least until I pause or close the app once again. Pathetic.
At least until I pause or close the app once again. Pathetic.
mikzn
macrumors 68040
I have see others post this issue too . . .
FWIW - I can drag a song to the "up next list" and it works for me - Big Sur 11.3 with Music 1.1.4.110 - am using song view / column view - dragging the song changes the list to indicate "Manually Added" and I can drag the song to any position in the "up next list"
Last edited:
derekww
macrumors member
for me, this skipping sometimes happens but only with mp3 files, and they always skip at around the 4 minute mark. :/
nortonandreev
Contributor