I upgraded my MacBook3,1 (Late 2007) to Yosemite yesterday.
I followed the guide on the first page of this topic, starting with a Mac AppStore download of Yosemite 10.10.1. It is a long process, and I thought I bricked my MacBook a couple of times, but it is doable if you have a couple of spare hours. You might save some time if you find the right patched Yosemite installation image online.
After installation and reboot, I first got the "no entry" sign, which required booting from the installation stick and deleting a plist file (see guide).
WiFi and Bluetooth worked out of the box.
Without graphics drivers, the system is barely usable. Not so much in terms of look and feel, but logging in and a number of other trivial operations seem to take ages.
With the beta X3100 graphics drivers, the system is much better although still feels slower than it should be at times: switching users in particular takes a lot more time that should be required. Disabling some graphic accelarations help somewhat. Normal operations on the other hand are OK - I ran Geekbench 3 and the score appears normal.
I got no sound out of the box after installation. I managed to get a faint, hissing sound after installing the Voodoo package. I'll look at it as I think some got it working better.
As reported by others, the system is not fully fonctional. Other than the above-mentionned slowness, here is what I noted (non exhaustive list):
- Videos do not play in VLC (missing OpenGL support) but other options work (QuickTime, Chrome)
- Maps does not show anything (probably requires OpenGL 4)
- Google Maps in Chrome works but is very slow and subject to glitches (broken beta drivers?)
- The latest iMovie won't install (unsupported graphic card)
- MacBook does not appear to properly go to sleep or hibernation modes but if sleep time has come, display goes black and there no way to recover it - you need to force shutdown and restart.
The last issue above is by far the one annoying me the most. You can mitigate it by setting the laptop to never sleep, even when running on battery. To avoid going to sleep with the lid closed, I understand you need the help of a soft such as this one:
http://code.google.com/p/macosx-nosleep-extension/
So, is it worth uppgrading? Probably not if this is your main machine and have no specific requirement for Yosemite features. My MacBook was running much better and more smoothly under Lion (with the possible exception of Safari which has got better).
But my MacBook is now running the latest versions of iWork, iPhoto... and syncs with the iCloud drive, which means that full interoperability has been restored with my other Apple machines (Macs, iPads and iPhones). That was the main reason for upgrading and the deal seems reasonable enough, especially if I can get fully working audio.
Now, if someone could get the sleep to work...