It's only an ok review imo. The whole thing has that slightly negative tone to it which is so typical for the Verge, you know when it sounds like they're kind of forced to admit how good a gadget is even though they've already decided to not like it for whatever reason.
And yeah he really only touched on the S Pen functionality. "...jot down notes, doodle, or navigate the phone’s interface..." isn't a very comprehensive summary of its functionality tbh. I do a lot of quick photo/screenshot editing as well as marking up documents, maps and stuff on my iPhone, man do I look forward to again having a S Pen for that.
To be fair I think he was actually speaking about it's function as a remote: "The new feature this year is the ability to use the button on it as a remote [...] It’s neat, but as someone who’s never really found much use for the S Pen, it isn’t something that I found very useful."
On that point I do feel the same; currently using an Apple Watch I'm not terribly impressed with a pen that lets me snap a photo when I'm not seeing a preview of how the subject is positioned etc., or skip forward in a playlist or whatever. I wish they'd taken a different route with evolving the S Pen: let the blunt end be an actual digital eraser, or maybe give it a microphone.
More than anything though I wish they'd focused on the S Pen related software. Of course I don't know how it'll work this time around but I suspect I'll still be missing the killer note taking app which trumps all others, something a stylus as good as the S Pen always has begged to have alongside it. And a simple option to "convert everything" on a screen off memo to machine text. Now you probably still have to save as a note, open note, draw lasso & select convert to text...
So I'm with the reviewer in that
software is where Samsung need to focus their efforts at this point. The Note 9 doesn't seem to come with almost anything new in this regard, aside from DeX which I personally can't see myself using...maybe ever. Just give me some straight up UX and S Pen related apps polishing though, and I'll bring out the champagne.
Lastly I really don't get the whole schtick of whining about the price. His whole review ends with "And having the most will cost you the most." Well...duh! $1099 is still cheaper than the 256GB iPhone X, right? Not to mention what the X Plus will cost... Bah. Flagship phones cost ~100 bucks and up nowadays, don't we already know that??
The Verge man...I just don't know. I'm looking forward more to the reviews from MKBHD, Tim Schofield, Flossy et al. But most of all from myself of course
dying to get my hands on that thing!!!