From my knowledge, I might be wrong here: I don’t believe available builds of High Sierra will work with titan ridge. The 2018 MacBook Pro was the first to use the controller and was released with a unique build, if memory recalls.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
MP 1,1-5,1 testing TB3 AIC with MP 5,1
- Thread starter Flint Ironstag
- Start date
-
- Tags
- cmp egpu gigabyte mojave 10.14 tb3
- Sort by reaction score
From my knowledge, I might be wrong here: I don’t believe available builds of High Sierra will work with titan ridge. The 2018 MacBook Pro was the first to use the controller and was released with a unique build, if memory recalls.
But we're not using the macOS to enable Titan Ridge. We're using Windows. Most of the macOS Thunderbolt software is not working but that's ok because all we need is the PCIe tunneling to be setup by Windows so that device drivers in macOS can see the devices. DisplayPort stuff is handled by the graphics drivers and goes through Thunderbolt controllers without help from the OS. The USB controller in the Titan Ridge is mostly a standard XHCI host controller and can therefore be handled by the standard XHCI driver. The only thing that requires more work is sleep/wake, hot plug, and other Thunderbolt services such as Thunderbolt networking, Target Display Mode, and Target Disk Mode.
The MacBook Pro 2018 (July 12) with Titan Ridge came out before Mojave (September). High Sierra 10.13.6 came out July 9, so it might be the same version as included with the MacBook Pro 2018. Anyway, there was a security update released October 30 and the version of High Sierra on my Hackintosh has mention of Titan Ridge.
IMHO, what needs work is trying to get this to function without booting to windows. That would be a big step. We need to spark the interest of someone creative and technically inclined enough to step up to this huge task. I know I would donate a few bucks to the cause!
How is the Linux support?
If there are Linux drivers for the card, they shouldn't be too hard to port to the macOS.
That’s a damn good question. Any distro you think would be best to test with?
Not sure, I don't own one of the cards, but I have interest in getting one when my fun budget allows it.
If the card works in a 3,1, and has linux drivers, I could take a stab at porting them to the macOS, I've done a few PCI devices in the past. It's been many years, and I'm sure I'll have to brush up, but it's likely something I could get a basic driver working so others could add to it.
Titan Ridge support has been added to the Linux kernel's Thunderbolt driver on March, 2.
And here is the driver itself.
P.S. I have received my GC-Titan Ridge card and my M.2 to PCIe riser (ordered the latter one to be able to plug the card into Highpoint SSD7101A) quite some time ago, but due to unforeseen circumstances I have no Thunderbolt devices on hand right now. But I'll test the card with my Highpoint controller in cMP4,1>5,1 tonight or tomorrow just to check if it'll give some useful information.
Me too. Has anyone tested this with a decent Audio I/O?
I would happily donate of necessary.
Go for it son! I've also asked my brother in law if he's keen. He's a Linux guy too.
Damn I'm excited about this too.. for audio use!
[doublepost=1542435618][/doublepost]
I'm creative and technically inclined. And interested. 20+ years of software dev experience too. A bit with Mac/Hackintosh but definitely need to brush up.
I would love to see Thunderbolt support.. For Audio/Studio use, I just never really felt the iMac/Mac Mini was up to the task really.. the Mac Pro is.. I would love to get Thunderbolt audio devices going, my firewire cards are showing their age.
I may have to order a card and join in on hacking..but I have a few things I need to solve first..I need boot screens (can't hack anything without that) and I don't have an appropriate card I do not believe. Then I want to upgrade my storage, NVMe preferably. Then TB3 would be great.
I may also need to invest in a 5,1. I have a 3,1 ATM. Money is up and down right now so we will have to see. It is my busy season for my business but I have been sick a lot lately so I haven't been able to take on as much work as I've wanted to..Which is part of why I'm back in front of the computer more lately..!
I'm definitely happy to devote some time/experience towards this though.
[doublepost=1542435618][/doublepost]
I'm creative and technically inclined. And interested. 20+ years of software dev experience too. A bit with Mac/Hackintosh but definitely need to brush up.
I would love to see Thunderbolt support.. For Audio/Studio use, I just never really felt the iMac/Mac Mini was up to the task really.. the Mac Pro is.. I would love to get Thunderbolt audio devices going, my firewire cards are showing their age.
I may have to order a card and join in on hacking..but I have a few things I need to solve first..I need boot screens (can't hack anything without that) and I don't have an appropriate card I do not believe. Then I want to upgrade my storage, NVMe preferably. Then TB3 would be great.
I may also need to invest in a 5,1. I have a 3,1 ATM. Money is up and down right now so we will have to see. It is my busy season for my business but I have been sick a lot lately so I haven't been able to take on as much work as I've wanted to..Which is part of why I'm back in front of the computer more lately..!
I'm definitely happy to devote some time/experience towards this though.
A couple other options besides using a m.2 to pcie x4 to pcie adapter monstrosity.
1. A non-standard usb header under the cpu tray is used for Bluetooth could be tapped.
2. The WiFi slot is mpcie 2.0 compatible. Populating it with a usb 2 adapter is also an internal option. Although finding a compatible chipset could be an issue.
For option 1, perhaps a hub could be wired to the header, allowing for both the connection to bluetooth and the TB3 adapter.
I've installed Ubuntu 18.04 on my MacPro3,1 using EFI mode (because Ubuntu's can handle the old EFI 1.1, unlike Windows). The thunderbolt drivers are there, but they don't expose the domain, devices, and nvm stuff. Connecting a Thunderbolt device does nothing (unlike in Windows on the same computer). Google /sys/bus/thunderbolt to learn about the linux thunderbolt drivers.
On my GA-Z170X Gaming 7 with built in Thunderbolt port (Alpine Ridge), /sys/bus/thunderbolt doesn't appear unless Thunderbolt is enabled in BIOS. The domain, devices, and nvm stuff don't appear until you connect a Thunderbolt device (after the os is booted).
On my GA-Z170X Gaming 7 with built in Thunderbolt port (Alpine Ridge), /sys/bus/thunderbolt doesn't appear unless Thunderbolt is enabled in BIOS. The domain, devices, and nvm stuff don't appear until you connect a Thunderbolt device (after the os is booted).
Last edited:
I got myself a really cheap Titan Ridge GC at a very good price could not resist and bought it, here a picture of what's on the PCB..
Now need to test under Mojave.
I want to see what in the Winbond chips... especially the one that has the green dot.. which I think is the rom...
Now need to test under Mojave.
I want to see what in the Winbond chips... especially the one that has the green dot.. which I think is the rom...
Attachments
the eGPU.io website has many pictures of Thunderbolt devices including the GC-TITAN RIDGE. Everyone of them has a windbond chip for the Thunderbolt firmware (and probably NVM storage?) I don't know why the GC-TITAN RIDGE has two of them.
So I've got an Asus eGPU enclosure hooked up to my Titan Ridge, and it works well on Windows.
On macos, after warm boot, my system recognises the Vega 56 in the eGPU and I'm even able to run Luxmark on it.
Video output is attempted but gives a grey screen on secondary monitor (plugged into the Vega), so something's going there.
Any suggestions?
On macos, after warm boot, my system recognises the Vega 56 in the eGPU and I'm even able to run Luxmark on it.
Video output is attempted but gives a grey screen on secondary monitor (plugged into the Vega), so something's going there.
Any suggestions?
The people at egpu.io have the same problem:
https://egpu.io/forums/builds/2010-...16gbps-tb3-mantiz-venus-win10-1803-theitsage/
I have to say I actually have all kind of issues installing windows?
Should I install Windows 7 and then upgrade?
Should I install Windows 7 and then upgrade?
1809 doesn't really like my Netstor
(TB AIC is in the Mac Pro, not in the Netstor, but I only get a blue screen at the beginning, and then the Mac restarts)