Hi everyone.
Long Story Short: I was coming from a Late 2013 MacBook Pro 13" and yesterday i picked up a 2019 MacBook Pro 15" from the Apple Store. And it's great!
Now, cue to the full story.
It's been a while, since I was thinking about upgrading my laptop to something newer and fresher; and after about 15 years of absolute devotion to Steve Jobs' Lovechild, I was scared about buying a new Mac, after reading all the complaints made by the angry 2016-17-18-19 MacBook Pro users.
So I was originally intended to buy a Dell XPS 7590 (2019 model) or a Lenovo Thinkpad X1Extreme 2019; but then my fiancé lent me his Dell XPS 9570 (the 2018 model)...
I had issues with the WiFi card which kept losing the connection (and it was replaced twice by Dell), it didn't have an ambient light sensor, the fans ramped up like crazy for everything, the speakers sounded bad and quite muffled, when you plugged in a pair of headphones you could hear a constant background hiss, you need to run a bunch of Dell Bloatware to change the screen profile or the power settings, etc.
And then the worst thing of them all: the fact that Windows 10 is not consistent when using HiDPI screens. Some things are big, some were as small as I couldn't read them. Just unbearable (for me, of course).
I must admit the screen on the Dell was quite gorgeous (and on the 7590 I ordered, I went for the OLED panel, which should have been even better); and I also liked the keyboard travel, I liked the overall look, I also liked that Dell allows you to check the battery level without opening the screen (glorious days when Apple allowed me to do the same thing on my 2006 Core Duo MacBook Pro...). I liked the build-quality, I liked that the nVidia 1050 Ti/1650 Max-Q is a very nice GPU (performing much better than the 560X and as good as the 300 Euros Vega 16), etc.
So I'm not saying that the Dell XPS is a bad product; just it wasn't good for me. And well...I decided to cancel the order because I arrived to the conclusion that, even if they're getting better and better every year, Windows laptops do not represent what I'm looking for in a portable machine.
So I jumped Michael Dell's ship; and even if I originally planned to wait until 2020 to see a new MacBook Pro with a refreshed keyboard, I decided to pull the trigger and replace my 2013 13" MacBook Pro with this brand new MacBook Pro 15" i9 8-core 2,3 GHz - 16GB - 512GB - 560X and I'm writing this very post on the new machine.
Coming from the 2013 13" MacBook Pro, short pills of what I have to say:
1) This machine is a beast; you can really feel all the power of the 8 core CPU. I ran a benchmark in Windows 10 and the throughput on the i9-9880H is quite something! Also, the SSD has a reading speed of 3200 MB/s and writing speed just south of 2 GB/s. Temperatures are comparable (sometimes lower) with the i5 dual-core of the Late 2013 MBP.
2) Even if the Dell had a 4K screen and this is "only" 2880x1800, I can't complain at all: also I run the MBP in 150% mode (so everything is scaled to look like 1900x1200) and I used to run my fiancé's Dell in 200% mode (so, 1920x1080). Colors are perfect, everything looks sharp and detailed. It's a masterpiece and it's even brighter than my 2013 13" monitor.
3) I'm using FileVault with real-time encrypting done by the T2 chip; so far, no T2 crashes.... Fingers crossed!
4) I put on my Windows 10 license and installed some modern games from the external SSD (Samsung T5 1TB; 540 MB/s); and I have to say that with a resolution of 1440x900 and medium settings, they're all pretty playable with stable 60fps! Of course, this machine is not intended to be a gaming laptop; but since I also own a Windows 10 Gaming PC, I installed Boot Camp just to do a bit of light gaming while away from home (e.g. during holidays).
5) When I ordered the MBP, I also thought about getting the Vega 20 instead of the 560X; but since I don't do any professional CAD or 3D work, I then realized I was going to spend 420 Euros for an upgrade just to get some better graphics in gaming and else, on a machine on which gaming performances are marginal.
6) I really like the feeling of the new-gen butterfly keyboard keyboard; the only things I dislike are the UP/DOWN arrows, as I often don't find them since they're way smaller than the other keys. I hope it's going to last a bit...
7) The touch-bar is odi et amo. It reminds me of my Apple Watch: it's nice to have it, but when I leave without wearing it, sometimes I don't even realize I left it at home.
I will update you as soon as possible; and I really hope the MacBook Pro will perform well and will not suffer from known issues like T2 crashes, broken keyboard, etc... Because I honestly find it well suited for my needs and right now there isn't another product on the market that (for me) could replace it if I decide to return it...
Last but not least, I bought with the Back To School program; so I had a free pair of Beats Studio3.
Just my 2 cents: they're nice, but I still prefer my Audio Technica ATH-M50x, to them. Nice that they gifted the headphones to me; but I would NEVER have spent 350 Euros for that things...
PS: for those of you who are not in Europe, 1 EUR = 1,12 USD