What exactly about these pictures is appealing to you? That is a serious question.
What I see in picture one is a shape with the very curved edges and chrome looking frame reminds me of the original iPhone, and the notch just screams out as ugh... worse in pictures that are landscape and its on the side. After a short time with the Note 8, those curved corners look dated to me. On the back, big hunk of camera sticking out like that on one corner messes up the symmetry on several levels. You can love the X or not, but looking at the pics I just don't get it.
Of course there is a narrative or agenda... that is why I challenged the notion that there is some big body of people running away from the Note 8. There are definitely comments from some of the supposed leavers that lead me to believe that they have never even used one.
If there is "not much different", why spend close to $1K to "upgrade"? That is where I found myself.
On the AW, my experience is completely the opposite of yours. Countless times the AW has told me to stand up when I was already doing something; or the annoying telling me to breath. The Gear S3 first off doesn't tell me to breath. It also doesn't tell me to just stand up. It tells me to stretch, do lateral twists, etc.. and it checks that I'm doing them. It automatically knows when I'm sleeping and tracks it. It knows when I'm working out and starts to track that. But the UI and rotating dial are just a better interface, particularly at the gym when you are sweaty.