From this thread it’s obvious most everyone wants the smallest size possible.
The few who don’t would rather go with the largest size possible and not the middle one. The ones who don’t fall in this camp, don’t want the smallest size only because they’ll miss out on essential features. So had the Pro offered a 5.4” model, they would have bought that instead of the 6.1”.
For almost nobody on this thread is price the main/only reason to go with 5.4”. It’s only the cherry on the top. You get the better sized phone. And it happens to be the cheaper one as well.
I have been saying this for ages. The iPhone 6 had the perfect dimensions. If you could make it very slightly smaller but full size, you’ve got a winner on your hand. And people will buy it regardless of how it is priced, of course within reason.
Something like the 5.4” iPhone is the perfect candidate for almost anybody coming from the SE/6-8/X/11 phone sizes. It’s what everybody has wanted all along. The only reason it won’t be the biggest success of all time is because many people also want every single feature available.
So had the iPhone and iPhone Pro both come in 5.4”, Apple would probably have got >70% of their new iPhone sales from just these two models.
I think this phone may just be the one to put the "Do people really want small phones?" question to bed. I believe many people sized up because there was no other option. Finally, we have the choice of a modern and small phone and people are jumping on it.
6.1" might just be a bad spot. Many thought it was popular due to existing sales (XR, etc) but that may have actually been due to the price and not the size. It may end up being "too small" for people who want a phablet and "too big" for people that want a pocketable phone. I know if there was a 5.8" Pro I'd have a tough choice.
Interestingly enough, the sizes people would buy are distributed equally (at the moment) between the 5,4” iPhone 12 and the 6,1 and 6,7” iPhone Pro models. Almost nobody wants the 6,1” iPhone.
I am predicting the opposite. The 6.1" Pro might be worst-selling device. Why?
* Phablet lovers who can afford it will get the 6.7" Pro
* Those who can't afford the Pro prices and want a big phone will get the 6.1" or an Android device
* Budget users will buy either the 5.4" or the 6.1" iPhone
* Those who want something small will obviously grab the 5.4"
* 6.1" isn't pocketable, at that size you might as well just size up to the 6.7"
This obviously depends on what features get cut from the non-Pro devices.