Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Will you leave the Apple ecosystem because of CSAM?


  • Total voters
    1,040
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Librem 5 is thick, heavy, the CPU is slow as ****, storage is abysmal, RAM is comically low, there is no hardware graphics acceleration, it's woefully overpriced when placed up against phones with similar specs (not talking about a $50 difference, but more like a $400 difference), and until a few months ago it was unable to actually make phone calls as it was released before it could (A phone that could not make phone calls. Think about that for a minute). But hey, at least it has a user replaceable battery and the g̶o̶v̶e̶r̶n̶m̶e̶n̶t̶ Apple isn't spying on you. So have fun.
....and it's one of our few options for the future. If we don't support this stuff today, future options won't be any better. Mac switchers can support the Linux ecosystem with their dollars.
 
There is in no way shape or form any kind of justification for charging $800 for a phone with 32GB of internal storage and 3GB RAM along with a quad-core slow-ass CPU and a screen with the resolution of 720×1440. Only idiots who are in fear that the government is going to find their deepest darkest secrets would shell out that much for such a pitiful device.
Purism is taking on a lot. From hardware to software, they're pushing everything to be open. open source hw/sw options will only improve with significant investment. Apple puts billions of dollars into R&D because we paid them to do it.
 
What does one do if the NAS gets destroyed somehow? Fire, flood etc. That's one of the reasons documents should be backed up off-site.
Yep, we need E2E encrypted cloud services that don't have surveillance features stuck in. Today's options aren't great, but it's all we've got. NextCloud? Open to ideas!
 
  • Like
Reactions: zakarhino
The Librem 5 is thick, heavy, the CPU is slow as ****, storage is abysmal, RAM is comically low, there is no hardware graphics acceleration, it's woefully overpriced when placed up against phones with similar specs (not talking about a $50 difference, but more like a $400 difference), and until a few months ago it was unable to actually make phone calls as it was released before it could (A phone that could not make phone calls. Think about that for a minute). But hey, at least it has a user replaceable battery and the g̶o̶v̶e̶r̶n̶m̶e̶n̶t̶ Apple isn't spying on you. So have fun.
Yes, but it runs full desktop Linux. Plug it into a monitor/keyboard/mouse and you suddenly have a full Linux desktop. No other phone can do that out of the box, not even the iPad.

It stands for more than specs. It's a bold move, like the original iPhone was in 2007. Sure, the iPhone 2g was junk, but it was totally different to anything else out there. Look where continued investment took it.

As for a phone that sucks as a phone, I think many smartphones today qualify. Nobody can hear me on my iPhone X, but I don't make phone calls anymore so I'd rather get battery life back. The Galaxy Notes are so comically large you might as well hold a tablet up to your ear.
 
What does one do if the NAS gets destroyed somehow? Fire, flood etc. That's one of the reasons documents should be backed up off-site.
Should be. Few bother. Of course we did for my employer, but I don't at home. I do rolling backups and the idle media is in a safe. I cross my fingers and hope that'll be sufficient. The alternatives would be the expense and hassle of a safe deposit box or maintaining a backup on somebody else's servers on the 'net. Neither is attractive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: I7guy
Yes, but it runs full desktop Linux. Plug it into a monitor/keyboard/mouse and you suddenly have a full Linux desktop. No other phone can do that out of the box, not even the iPad.

It stands for more than specs. It's a bold move, like the original iPhone was in 2007. Sure, the iPhone 2g was junk, but it was totally different to anything else out there. Look where continued investment took it.

As for a phone that sucks as a phone, I think many smartphones today qualify. Nobody can hear me on my iPhone X, but I don't make phone calls anymore so I'd rather get battery life back. The Galaxy Notes are so comically large you might as well hold a tablet up to your ear.
I like this comparison. Librem 5 is like the iPhone in 2007. Or the Apple II in the 80s. An important beginning.
 
What does one do if the NAS gets destroyed somehow? Fire, flood etc. That's one of the reasons documents should be backed up off-site.

Right now I have spinner HDDs that I rotate offsite. Ultimately I want a cloud storage solution for backup but am still in the research phase. Synology is about to launch an encrypted service which would be appealing but it all depends on the security/privacy.

 
What does one do if the NAS gets destroyed somehow? Fire, flood etc. That's one of the reasons documents should be backed up off-site.
That’s standard practice for any data.
im using

For speed its also backed up locally.
 
Last edited:
This scandal has made me reevaluate what I use my devices for and how I use them. I’m actually kinda glad it happened because now I have a clear idea what I value in my devices and my behavior using them.

I’ll definitely stay in the ecosystem, but any files I feel that governments would find “questionable” (for example, my gunsmithing guides) I’ll be careful to not keep in easily surveillable places. Likewise anything else that I would like to keep private.

I know now that I value my Apple devices for convenience and work. For the time being I’ll still trust that they’re not scanning my financial information any more than the institutions that I use.

On that last point, I know that scanning on my devices is probably the least effective method of detecting wrongthink on my part. My ISP, the sites I get my files, and where I chat with friends are far bigger threat vectors than Apple. And it’s not like I make my anti-government views a secret. So looking at it that way it doesn’t affect me.
 
Well, if Windows allows you to play those games that are so important to you, then you actually have reason to be happy with it. Can't have it both ways. You are providing proof of Windows value. Microsoft has and still puts a lot of effort into making Windows game ready, direct X, etc. In Windows 11 they are incorporating auto HDR. It does not matter to Microsoft why you use Windows only that you use Windows.
Just because it's my only option doesn't mean I have to think it's good or that I have to like it.

Not a single new addition to Windows 11 benefits me (My graphics card doesn't support DirectStorage, I don't have an HDR monitor).

I didn't think it ever mattered to Microsoft how I used Windows either. I know it doesn't matter to them. As long as I'm using it. That doesn't mean I have enjoy using it. It doesn't mean I have to accept Windows as good.

Windows is a dumpster fire in my opinion and it's been a dumpster fire since as long as I've been using it (Windows 98). Because it's my only option to play a few games with mouse and keyboard isn't going to change that.
 
Right now I have spinner HDDs that I rotate offsite. Ultimately I want a cloud storage solution for backup but am still in the research phase. Synology is about to launch an encrypted service which would be appealing but it all depends on the security/privacy.

It gets down to who do you trust most with your data. A few years down the line is Synology going to be in business? What happens if they cease operations due to low subscriber count?
That’s standard practice for any data.
im using

For speed its also backed up locally.
My windows boxes are under control and I have a manual backup and a website that I upload to. If anything were to change I would have to figure out how to manage the 10 years and thousands of photos in icloud. Plus all of the good stuff in messages.
 
Last edited:
Right now I have spinner HDDs that I rotate offsite. Ultimately I want a cloud storage solution for backup but am still in the research phase. Synology is about to launch an encrypted service which would be appealing but it all depends on the security/privacy.

Keep us posted on what you find!
 
Just because it's my only option doesn't mean I have to think it's good or that I have to like it.
Agreed, feel the same way about Linux today. I don't think it's good and I don't like it. It has a long way to go. But it's my only option and I believe it has to succeed long term. So I'm dropping my non-open devices and plunging in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CasualFanboy
It doesn't affect you, but what about others? Journalists, whistleblowers, others with non-standard views?

I switched to Linux to support privacy for those people. I support Tor for the same reasons.
Oh, I didn’t mean to come across like I support this change. I certainly don’t and think it’s a horrible breach of trust, especially coming from a company that marketed itself on privacy. And I agree the system can and will be abused.

My post was on my personal use case. I like the concept of open software myself and would contribute to it if I could (the small amount of programming knowledge I have wouldn’t be any use) but aside from tinkering Linux doesn’t suit my needs.
 
My girlfriend is pretty gutted about this situation. She was about to switch from her Samsung to iPhone when I told her I was going to jump ship away from Apple. When I explained why she was totally confused on why Apple would try this.

She was born in a former Soviet Union state and totally understands what spying is all about.

I'm glad that she didn't actually switch though. Better to have called it out now rather than later.

Nothing else is as polished as Apple's ecosystem but now it's like a rotten garden. Everything is happy smiley on the outside but inside it's going to be a seething mess.

I guess I prefer my messes on the outside, at least it can be seen and addressed rather than swept under an Apple rug.

Still trying to decide on which phone to move to, Galaxy Fold 3 looks nice enough but the whole camera locking thing smacks of Apple hubris, Pixel 6 Pro is due soon. Still interested in the F(x)tec Pro1, I used to rock a Danger Sidekick 20 years ago. New Surface announcements later this month too, hopefully MS can finally deliver decent software/hardware for their phones.

My biggest problem will be weaning myself off of Applepay/Handoff/Continuity/Airdrop/iMessage/watch. I don't think any of the competition is anywhere near as polished or integrated for those features. I have 3 Macs and 2 iPads to replace along with an iPhone.

Thanks Tim Apple.
 
How do people here feel about Backblaze?

I have friends and family that use it and love it. I've been thinking of trying it out myself because of the ability to use a private key for encryption so Backblaze are incapable of reading my data.
 
Never used them but I like their blog. Good drive reliability stats that no one else seems to publish.

Very timely:
I’ve been using them for off site backup of my Mac for about a year now.
 
There is in no way shape or form any kind of justification for charging $800 for a phone with 32GB of internal storage and 3GB RAM along with a quad-core slow-ass CPU and a screen with the resolution of 720×1440. Only idiots who are in fear that the government is going to find their deepest darkest secrets would shell out that much for such a pitiful device.
Are the spec really that bad? Guess I will pass as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.