Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone XS I'm on my 16th iPhone Xs
- Thread starter PumpkingKing
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
So you would be okay with dust behind the camera glass and the other faults listed?
That’s okay, but you can’t fault him for not being okay with it. I wouldn’t be. Apple is at fault. Seems like many people just can’t get that last sentence out of their throats.
There’s no way I would go through 16 iPhone’s. I would jump off the iPhone ship, and switch brands first. That’s ridiculous in my book. My XS is fine for me. I don’t see anything wrong with it, but I’m sure the op would have returned mine as well.
I just finished reading this thread and I am amazed with so many posts blaming the OP for a situation is just simply unnacceptable.
Apple prices are far from being reasonable, due to the perfection, precision, high level of quality.
Can anyone explain to me how come it is acceptable to keep a new phone with dust on camera lenses, considering this is a dust and water resistant phone?
Honestly, if I buy a Samsung, Huawei or other brand phone costing a third this costs, I get no such issues!
And all people say is that customers have to bare with this, because there is no way to get a perfect device?
As far as I can tell, the op wants to get a device with at least the same quality level other brands happen to deliver.
And just for the record: I got today my 3rd iPhone XS, 2 of them with dust specs on camera, the third one had a deep scratch on back glass out of the box.
If I accept to pay that much for Apple products, as I expect great quality from them, I cannot accept this type of defects out of the box.
And classifying that as OCD is just a nonsense!
Apple quality control is just crap, and til customers start to let them know they expect to pay for products with no production issues, they will keep selling low quality produced products and charging premium prices for all of them.
It's as simple as that.
Apple prices are far from being reasonable, due to the perfection, precision, high level of quality.
Can anyone explain to me how come it is acceptable to keep a new phone with dust on camera lenses, considering this is a dust and water resistant phone?
Honestly, if I buy a Samsung, Huawei or other brand phone costing a third this costs, I get no such issues!
And all people say is that customers have to bare with this, because there is no way to get a perfect device?
As far as I can tell, the op wants to get a device with at least the same quality level other brands happen to deliver.
And just for the record: I got today my 3rd iPhone XS, 2 of them with dust specs on camera, the third one had a deep scratch on back glass out of the box.
If I accept to pay that much for Apple products, as I expect great quality from them, I cannot accept this type of defects out of the box.
And classifying that as OCD is just a nonsense!
Apple quality control is just crap, and til customers start to let them know they expect to pay for products with no production issues, they will keep selling low quality produced products and charging premium prices for all of them.
It's as simple as that.
Last edited:
Agreed, wrote the same thing on the previous page.
It’s baffling. And the notion that rejecting a phone is ‘a waste’ suggests that Apple just throws these phones away, but they’ll just be repaired. How many defective phones do they take in every day world wide anyway?
When the majority of your user base cares more about poop emojis and Instagram over anything else, why would you spend additional resources on or care about quality control. Most people don't care and Apple laughs all the way to the bank.
Last edited:
My standard response to celestial threads like this one adjust your expectations or two move on.
What does it matter? Apple permitted the OP to make the returns, so in theory, they can make as many returns they want until Apple restricts them otherwise. And clearly Apple is allowing this, so it shouldn’t be a problem for anyone other than the OP sharing their experiences. Now, for example, if the OP was complaining if Apple was limiting the returns, that would be different. But Apple is granting the OP until they say otherwise.
That’s true. Especially if you’ve bought LOTS of apple products year over year. They probably let the limit slide to keep the relationship long term
I’m glad that this definitely is a multiple country affliction on the phones, in the sense that I am not alone in dealing with their production quality, and at least some others might possibly speak up, rather than me somehow just having had that many bad iPhones in Australia. Thanks for the indirect defense some of you are providing in response to the ridiculous and unnecessary comments being posted here. Agreed defective is defective, how anyone can accept a device that’s defective is beyond me, but each to their own.
To update my situation, I have a replacement organized for that Max I received with the dust in the lens. Hopefully I can at a minimum get a dust-free product by Tuesday or Wednesday, and if there’s any other issue, I’m just going to try and take advantage of the extended return and just make another exchange in early January.
To update my situation, I have a replacement organized for that Max I received with the dust in the lens. Hopefully I can at a minimum get a dust-free product by Tuesday or Wednesday, and if there’s any other issue, I’m just going to try and take advantage of the extended return and just make another exchange in early January.
Have you considered an XR and waiting for next years flagship?
Though I’m positive there’s Xr duds much better yield in general screen and build wise imo. And stellar battery
I can almost bet if the OP leaves Apple, and goes to perhaps Google or Samsung, he will come up with the same complaints with their phones.
Guaranteed
Guaranteed
A little, but in the next week I’m definitely going to give it further thought and weigh up the pros and cons.
If Apple is going to charge this much for devices, they deserve every return they get if the devices aren't perfect in every way. They invited that when they chose to upcharge so much. You gotta have a really irrational love of a corporation to side with Apple on this.
I would never pick up Samsung, their bloatware ruins their phones.
If I didn’t use the icloud ecosystem, I’d go with google for sure, for their great software and inexpensive phones. Also, you should either read the entire thread or leave since you clearly wish to show, or can’t help but show, your lack of intelligence in your post.
[doublepost=1542466271][/doublepost]
Good point
On a side note:
One thing I find disappointing with Apple, if you have a defective device, and you contact Apple and request a warranty device, they now charge you $30 to ship the phone to you express if you *don’t* have Applecare Plus. If you have AppleCare Plus, then they don’t charge you the $30. In the years past, Apple would always send you The replacement device _without_ charging you the shipping fee within two business days.
As a customer with a defective device, I feel they shouldn’t have to charge you the $30 to ship you a new phone when you have a defective device that’s out of the customers control to begin with. [And Apple cannot dismiss/waiver the $30.00 ship fee either.]
One thing I find disappointing with Apple, if you have a defective device, and you contact Apple and request a warranty device, they now charge you $30 to ship the phone to you express if you *don’t* have Applecare Plus. If you have AppleCare Plus, then they don’t charge you the $30. In the years past, Apple would always send you The replacement device _without_ charging you the shipping fee within two business days.
As a customer with a defective device, I feel they shouldn’t have to charge you the $30 to ship you a new phone when you have a defective device that’s out of the customers control to begin with. [And Apple cannot dismiss/waiver the $30.00 ship fee either.]
It is possible the store got a bad batch, it does happen despite the QC. I work a lot with servers and bought 12 3TB WD Black drives a few years back, every single drive failed within days of each other. When I checked the serials they were 001, 002, 003, 004, 005 and so on, even WD admitted it was a manufacturing fault in a particular range.
16 does seem a lot though, either it was a bad batch or a couple that were not up to par then being overly picky afterwards.
16 does seem a lot though, either it was a bad batch or a couple that were not up to par then being overly picky afterwards.
Seems perfectly plausible that the store received a bad batch of phones. People on this site just love defending Apple. Perhaps Apple should look at thier ever declining quality control. Still can't believe some of the replies in this thread, accusing the op of everything under the sun. So sad.
Actually, it’s not. I’m 26 years old. ‘Trolling’ is a teen word, not in my vocabulary.
[doublepost=1542558476][/doublepost]
I’m thinking it’s more like an international issue with some people in other countries noticing some of the defects as well. But it is still possible that maybe the majority came here or something.
I’m curious .. have you seen any display / demo units at the store that have wow’d ya?
How long ya gonna keep this golden goose if you find it? Worried about breaking it?
Yeah...most apple fans are too in love with apple to think they could ever do wrong. Plus many of them probably just don’t have an eye or a care for this type of thing, and majority who make the comments probably don’t have one of the new iPhones themselves.
[doublepost=1542558880][/doublepost]
Demo units are afflicted unfortunately, so no. 3 years is the goal. Once warranty runs out I usually figure that I keep what I have unless something really stands out that I think I’d appreciate in terms of hardware, features and convenience.
Not worried about breaking it because I often don’t break / drop / damage any of what I buy. I often don’t use a case on the phone in particular since it’s just so nice to hold (usually), unless I need to sit it somewhere or I know I’m going somewhere that might be potentially dangerous for the phone, I’ll chuck on the silicone case.