No, I wouldn't.
As the first universally accepted status symbol in the smartphone universe, the iPhone X needed something to visually set it apart from the riff-raff out there. If it went edge-to-edge, it would look like all those cheap Android phones that unwashed gamer high school students are seen with. If it had the home button, forehead, and chin, it would look like all those old and cheap used iPhones bought off of Craigslist for $49 that day laborers are seen with.
We don't care if it is a notch, a vertical camera, or a pink pierced nipple ring, the iPhone X needed something visually different and noticeable to passers-by in order to justify it's $1,200 price. Without the notch we're using a ho-hum iPhone that no one would notice and could be as old as 2012. With the notch, we're celebrities, I'm Tom Cruise, people lean over my shoulder on a train to take a look, people strike up idle conversation with me at the airport gate.
Once you get past the first month and the afterglow of the new technology, the X becomes just-a-phone. But the notch is what keeps it spicy, it's what makes the X keep giving its owners exciting vibes each week. The attention it draws is fantastic, like having a Ferrari in your pocket.