Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.

Larsvonhier

macrumors 68000
Aug 21, 2016
1,611
2,983
Germany, Black Forest
SMC reset on earlier Macbooks involve opening the machine and disconnecting the battery. Did you go that far? That trackpad is on the USB bus and should show up in System Information if connected. Can an earlier macOS on an external drive be booted to test for a potential hardware failure? As I recall the CP experiment was for the MB5,2 trackpad issue. Best of luck, others may chime in? If @TimothyR734 is still around, he may remember? There is also our founder @0403979 He may know? 🤨
Some clarifications for the ones (and 2s ;-) who don´t own or operate a MBP4,1 in unsupported macOS land:

With the MBP4,1 it´s easy to take the battery out (just two spring sliders that have to be pushed).
The CP replacement was intended (and needed) for MB5,2 only.
Dosdude1 hinted me to a peculiar situation years ago: It´s possible to replace the top cover incl. trackpad with the one from a MBP3,1 - seems all well then, but certain trackpad functions are not supported then any more. As it is hard to tell the difference from the outside, ppl might think it´s the normal faulty MBP4,1 behaviour then.

So, as K two also suggested, the easiest check is to boot a previous known-working installation and see if special trackpad functions are there then.

Another (real) speciality is the CFL backlight in non-glare (matte) screen versions of this machine. Support for function-key-changing the screen brightness is gone since a while (10.15.4 or so...). The old patches that dosdude1 had months ago still partly work: No problem when no external screen is connected, but crashes when present. Way around this is the free "brightness slider" app from the app store.
 

Larsvonhier

macrumors 68000
Aug 21, 2016
1,611
2,983
Germany, Black Forest
Latest beta sec. update 2021 also up and running fine on MP3,1 here.
Just the usual procedure and "force kernel cache rebuild" with dosdude1´s post-install patches.

Bildschirmfoto 2021-03-30 um 09.56.24.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: K two

roysterdoyster

macrumors 6502
Jul 3, 2017
402
430
Have you tried to re-install the @dosdude1 patches from the Patch Updater app in the Utilities ƒ ? You can update an individual patch by Control key selection. Start with the Legacy USB patch. Just a thought. 😎
I did. Same result. But I can live with the partial functioning of the trackpad, it's a small price for having my MBP4,1 running on the latest Catalina build. The keyboard backlight keys stopped working a year ago or so, I found a workaround with LabTick. Maybe in time I will find a solution for the trackpad, or a new patch comes out, or a Catalina update.

Thank you very much K Two, you are a great board member!
 
  • Like
Reactions: K two

Larsvonhier

macrumors 68000
Aug 21, 2016
1,611
2,983
Germany, Black Forest
I did. Same result. But I can live with the partial functioning of the trackpad, it's a small price for having my MBP4,1 running on the latest Catalina build. The keyboard backlight keys stopped working a year ago or so, I found a workaround with LabTick. Maybe in time I will find a solution for the trackpad, or a new patch comes out, or a Catalina update.

Thank you very much K Two, you are a great board member!
Can you send a photo of the small trackpad PCB that´s visible when taking out the battery? That would clarify/rule out MBP3,1 trackpad confusion, just to rule out that pitfall.
 

thomasonlineva

macrumors newbie
Apr 12, 2020
18
11
updated using:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CatalinaPatcher/comments/mg17w9
but after the core update i reran to get the beta update.

Added from #13,967 below:

Fairly complete instruction with a few caveats.

Often, if the OTA Update Fix is not applied early in the D/L progress the update will fail and boot normally. When this occurs go to Library/Updates ƒ and delete everything within, then retry. If the OTA Update Fix is fully applied, items on the Desktop will disappear, twice and re-appear.

There is an additional step required for unpatched ROM Macs which requires a USBOpenCoreAPFSloader3.app or OC4b USB by @jackluke to find macOS Installer to complete.

Please see this post below for needed files
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2021-03-30 at 7.11.47 PM.jpg
    Screen Shot 2021-03-30 at 7.11.47 PM.jpg
    38.7 KB · Views: 496
Last edited:

roysterdoyster

macrumors 6502
Jul 3, 2017
402
430
Can you send a photo of the small trackpad PCB that´s visible when taking out the battery? That would clarify/rule out MBP3,1 trackpad confusion, just to rule out that pitfall.
Sure, here's the photo (MBP4,1 17-inch, Early 2008, Battery taken out.)
Can you advise further from here? Thanks in advance for looking into it.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5402.jpg
    IMG_5402.jpg
    1.4 MB · Views: 129
  • Like
Reactions: K two

RogueB

macrumors 6502
Sep 9, 2016
272
471
Hello to all,

Reporting successful installation of latest (beta developer ?) supplement resulting in:
System Version: macOS 10.15.7 (19H1026)
Used method as described in post #13,956 on this page (see above)

I did experience a freeze after last reboot in the install process, however, resolved this by shutting down MacBook Pro by pressing (and holding) power button, then rebooting into the USB stick with dosdudes1's patcher, applying patches, rebuilding caches and restarting. Note, that it took several attempts before patches took hold. On few reboots patches were not active; I had to activate patcher updater (in utilities folder) before successfully patching, then rebooting the system.
All functions seem available.
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2021-04-01 at 6.56.30 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2021-04-01 at 6.56.30 PM.png
    101.4 KB · Views: 97
Last edited:

danyMRF

macrumors newbie
Apr 24, 2017
25
4
Hello everyone,

I own a Mac mini (Late 2009) which originally had 2GB (2x1GB) of RAM, but over the years I had expanded to 4GB (2x2GB) and replaced the internal HD with an SSD and then due to a bad memory bank, I had to downgrade to 3GB (1x1GB + 1x2GB).

On the internal SSD of this Macmini3,1 I installed the latest officially supported operating system OS X El Capitan 10.11.6 but in order to use the most recent versions of Xcode (and the iOS SDKs) I had to install on an external HD first Sierra and then High Sierra with dosdude1 patchers. Currently on another external SSD I also use Mojave 10.14.6 with the dosdude1 patcher and Xcode 11 (only the IDE because the included iOS simulator does not run with less than 4 GB).

Now in order to use Xcode 12 (with the iOS 14 SDK) I necessarily need macOS Catalina (which I see, for example @K two , that it is possible to install on Macmini3,1 always thanks to the dosdude1 patcher) but I read in the technical specifications that Catalina, unlike the previous operating systems, requires 4 GB.

Has anyone managed to install it with less than 4GB of memory? That is, does it work unsatisfactorily or is it just not possible to install it? What about Xcode 12?

I thank everyone in advance for the answers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: K two

Tweedynamite

macrumors newbie
Apr 2, 2021
6
6
Hello everyone and thanks for the amazing job.

Catalina runs fine on my late 2008 MacBook unibody (5.1), with 8gb of ram and a SSD, except some issues :

- I’m unable to read Dolby vision videos from my IPhone 12 Pro (color profile is bt.2020 hlg (9-18-9). When I just pass the mouse pointer on it, the screen turns black, it logs me off and puts me in the login screen. It happens in Photo app and in the finder as well. If I disable HDR in my iPhone video settings I don’t have this problem, but video playback is generally very laggy (with VLC, QuickTime, IMovie) even with clips coming from my previous iPhone XS.

- Siri only works from time to time. I guess it takes a lot of CPU ressource on my old computer.

- Hibernate mode doesn’t work, the MacBook simply shuts down if the battery is out of charge. It seems to be a known issue. Does it work with Mojave ?

- I have verbose APFS white and yellow text when booting. I think it’s normal since I’m scared to use the APFS ROM patcher tool. Did anyone use this tool on the same Mac as mine without bricking is machine ? Is there a way to simply hide this log and have a grey screen when booting (without updating firmware).

Thanks in advance for your replies. I’m wondering if I should just downgrade to Mojave to have better luck with video playback (I haven’t test it yet). Specific Catalina features like Sidecar and automatic dark mode don’t work on my device anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: K two

K two

macrumors 68020
Dec 6, 2018
2,310
3,178
North America
Hello everyone,

I own a Mac mini (Late 2009) which originally had 2GB (2x1GB) of RAM, but over the years I had expanded to 4GB (2x2GB) and replaced the internal HD with an SSD and then due to a bad memory bank, I had to downgrade to 3GB (1x1GB + 1x2GB).

On the internal SSD of this Macmini3,1 I installed the latest officially supported operating system OS X El Capitan 10.11.6 but in order to use the most recent versions of Xcode (and the iOS SDKs) I had to install on an external HD first Sierra and then High Sierra with dosdude1 patchers. Currently on another external SSD I also use Mojave 10.14.6 with the dosdude1 patcher and Xcode 11 (only the IDE because the included iOS simulator does not run with less than 4 GB).

Now in order to use Xcode 12 (with the iOS 14 SDK) I necessarily need macOS Catalina (which I see, for example @K two , that it is possible to install on Macmini3,1 always thanks to the dosdude1 patcher) but I read in the technical specifications that Catalina, unlike the previous operating systems, requires 4 GB.

Has anyone managed to install it with less than 4GB of memory? That is, does it work unsatisfactorily or is it just not possible to install it? What about Xcode 12?

I thank everyone in advance for the answers.
Strongly recommend 8 GB RAM which is inexpensive, here: https://eshop.macsales.com/item/OWC/8566DDR3S8GP/ may provide what you need for <$45.
 
  • Like
Reactions: makra

K two

macrumors 68020
Dec 6, 2018
2,310
3,178
North America
Hello everyone and thanks for the amazing job.

Catalina runs fine on my late 2008 MacBook unibody (5.1), with 8gb of ram and a SSD, except some issues :

- I’m unable to read Dolby vision videos from my IPhone 12 Pro (color profile is bt.2020 hlg (9-18-9). When I just pass the mouse pointer on it, the screen turns black, it logs me off and puts me in the login screen. It happens in Photo app and in the finder as well. If I disable HDR in my iPhone video settings I don’t have this problem, but video playback is generally very laggy (with VLC, QuickTime, IMovie) even with clips coming from my previous iPhone XS.

- Siri only works from time to time. I guess it takes a lot of CPU ressource on my old computer.

- Hibernate mode doesn’t work, the MacBook simply shuts down if the battery is out of charge. It seems to be a known issue. Does it work with Mojave ?

- I have verbose APFS white and yellow text when booting. I think it’s normal since I’m scared to use the APFS ROM patcher tool. Did anyone use this tool on the same Mac as mine without bricking is machine ? Is there a way to simply hide this log and have a grey screen when booting (without updating firmware).

Thanks in advance for your replies. I’m wondering if I should just downgrade to Mojave to have better luck with video playback (I haven’t test it yet). Specific Catalina features like Sidecar and automatic dark mode don’t work on my device anyway.

Risking the MB5,1 over an inconsequential start-up screen artifact from the APFS Patch may not be worth rolling the dice? Kept our unpatched Aluminum MB5,1 on Mojave because it was MUCH easier to update and 32bit apps are still employed. Thanks for the Catalina observations. Very useful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hvds

Tweedynamite

macrumors newbie
Apr 2, 2021
6
6
You’re right, I’ll keep the APFS patch, it’s not worth it.

How about Mojave on your MB 5.1 ? Do you experience problems while playing video (lags, freezes) ? Everything works fine including hibernation mode and Siri ? Do you thinks there will be a lack of performance if I downgrade from Catalina ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: K two

Tweedynamite

macrumors newbie
Apr 2, 2021
6
6
Risking the MB5,1 over an inconsequential start-up screen artifact from the APFS Patch may not be worth rolling the dice? Kept our unpatched Aluminum MB5,1 on Mojave because it was MUCH easier to update and 32bit apps are still employed. Thanks for the Catalina observations. Very useful.
You’re right, I’ll keep the APFS patch, it’s not worth it.

How about Mojave on your MB 5.1 ? Do you experience problems while playing video (lags, freezes) ? Everything works fine including hibernation mode and Siri ? Do you thinks there will be a lack of performance if I downgrade from Catalina ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: K two

K two

macrumors 68020
Dec 6, 2018
2,310
3,178
North America
You’re right, I’ll keep the APFS patch, it’s not worth it.

How about Mojave on your MB 5.1 ? Do you experience problems while playing video (lags, freezes) ? Everything works fine including hibernation mode and Siri ? Do you thinks there will be a lack of performance if I downgrade from Catalina ?

Performance is acceptable for our useage. Some remove and replace the Apple GVA Framework to eek-out a higher video frame rate. See the Mojave on unsupported Macs thread for details, try #18,692 on p.748. Use caution. 🧐
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tweedynamite

K two

macrumors 68020
Dec 6, 2018
2,310
3,178
North America
updated using https://www.reddit.com/r/CatalinaPatcher/comments/mg17w9
but after the core update i reran to get the beta update.

Fairly complete instruction with a few caveats.

Often, if the OTA Update Fix is not applied early in the D/L progress the update will fail and boot normally. When this occurs go to Library/Updates ƒ and delete everything within, then retry. If the OTA Update Fix is fully applied, items on the Desktop will disappear, twice and re-appear.

There is an additional step required for unpatched ROM Macs which requires a USBOpenCoreAPFSloader3.app or OC4b USB by @jackluke to find macOS Installer to complete.
 

Ausdauersportler

macrumors 603
Nov 25, 2019
5,007
5,826
Fairly complete instruction with a few caveats.

Often, if the OTA Update Fix is not applied early in the D/L progress the update will fail and boot normally. When this occurs go to Library/Updates ƒ and delete everything within, then retry. If the OTA Update Fix is fully applied, items on the Desktop will disappear, twice and re-appear.

There is an additional step required for unpatched ROM Macs which requires a USBOpenCoreAPFSloader3.app or OC4b USB by @jackluke to find macOS Installer to complete.
I told you, you should have added your more complete instruction set (including links to the tools to be used) long time ago to the first post! It does not really matter who developed all the tools...I matters who cares now!
 
  • Like
Reactions: pullman and makra

K two

macrumors 68020
Dec 6, 2018
2,310
3,178
North America
I told you, you should have added your more complete instruction set (including links to the tools to be used) long time ago to the first post! It does not really matter who developed all the tools...I matters who cares now!
Being tactical rather than encyclopedic is more useful.IMHO Besides, https://forums.macrumors.com/members/thomasonlineva.1212565/ did an adequate presentation for the majority of users. But as requested here are the tools cited <attached> Also threw in gibMacOS-master to acquire the latest official macOS installers from Apple.
 

Attachments

  • CatalinaOTAswufix.app.zip
    152.7 KB · Views: 180
  • gibMacOS-master.zip
    505.4 KB · Views: 136
  • OpenCore4b1.zip
    6.2 MB · Views: 127
  • USBOpenCoreAPFSloader3.app.zip
    155.4 KB · Views: 144
Last edited:

Ausdauersportler

macrumors 603
Nov 25, 2019
5,007
5,826
Being tactical rather tha encyclopedic is more useful.IMHO Besides, https://forums.macrumors.com/members/thomasonlineva.1212565/ did an adequate presentation for the majority of users. But as requested here are the tools cited <attached> Also threw in gibMacOS-master to acquire the latest official macOS installers from Apple.
This is a moving target, but a complex process at the same time. To get it done it is always useful to teach the basics while helping in corner cases. Otherwise you could offer a mail in services to upgrade legacy Macs :)
 
  • Haha
  • Wow
Reactions: pullman and K two

hvds

macrumors 6502a
Sep 1, 2017
848
2,019
Switzerland
I re-replaced the stock .4b5 MonitorPanels and MonitorPanel.framework (compiled by apple on 7 March 2020) , and using the new @ASentientBot 4b5 wrappers the Displays.prefpane worked with stock MonitorPanel* , also the brightness slider, except the "Night Shift tab" that as @indiawallah tested is due to a pre-4beta MonitorPanel.framework , so @ASentientBot you might check something on the privateframework MonitorPanel unix exec if there is some call to com.apple.preference.displays displaysNightShiftTab (but as workaround shifty app works).

Also another question, how do you showed on your MacBook7,1 the "Retina Text size" on 4b5 Displays.prefpane ? (I guess it's a casual bug?)

Because you have "Optimize for" and "NO_LOC" , and also you don't have the brightness slider while I have using your recent 4b5 wrappers and stock 4b5 MonitorPanel*.
On my MBP5,2, in the Monitors prefpane the brightness slider and the automatic brightness adjust checkbox were missing since a while. On 19H524 at present.
Not a big deal of course, nevertheless just re-installed jackluke's fixes for the panel, and the items are back. (I had installed the Night Shift patch earlier via Patch Updater).
MonitorPanels, MonitorPanel.frameworks, and a small script to install them are in the attached zip. No reboot necessary.
 

Attachments

  • Bildschirmfoto 2021-04-03 um 11.07.42.png
    Bildschirmfoto 2021-04-03 um 11.07.42.png
    85 KB · Views: 104
  • MonitorPanel June 2020.zip
    5.3 MB · Views: 126

K two

macrumors 68020
Dec 6, 2018
2,310
3,178
North America
This is a moving target, but a complex process at the same time. To get it done it is always useful to teach the basics while helping in corner cases. Otherwise you could offer a mail in services to upgrade legacy Macs :)
The basics are built-in to the two @jackluke apps, immediately available upon running the app which is how most learn to use. gib assumes shell scripts can be read. OC4b is unzipped onto a USB formatted the same as the @dosdude1 patcher except with Master Boot Record as opposed to GUID partitions selected in Disk Utility. EFI Boot ƒ on top. https://forums.macrumors.com/thread....2242172/page-221?post=29138842#post-29138842 and https://github.com/jacklukem/BigSurfixes/releases/
 
Last edited:

fussel132

macrumors newbie
Mar 25, 2021
4
2
Hey guys,
finally, I can commit my problem to you. It all started like a week ago when I discovered the Continuity Activation Tool. I am a happy owner of a MacBook Pro 2010 13" (MacBookPro7,1 - BoardID: Mac-F222BEC8) I was given for free last year. It came broken and not operational, but I fixed that and after upgrading RAM and SSD and so on, I installed @dosdude1 's Catalina Patcher (works like a charm, thanks!) and used it for a while, knowing that it is now 10 years old and simply don't support features like Handoff, Airdrop / Airplay and so. As a Windows User I never had experience with Macs before and if something I'll write below is completely wrong or garbage, I apologize for that ;).
But back last week where I stumbled over the CAT-Tool I was interested again in experimenting further with my MacBook. A quick fresh installation of Catalina on another drive and the experimenting could begin! Downloading CAT, not reading anything, just installing and so my first kernel panic was born. I then read that the tool is only supported till OS 10.12 and did some further research on the issue online. I quickly found this thread and began to puzzle together an instruction from the contributions by @jackluke . Doing so, I came to the following result, how to activate continuity features in MacOS Catalina on unsupported Macs:

1. Required Hardware:
For using those features, I would need at least Bluetooth 4.0 supported by my Mac, I found the BCM94331PCIEBT4CAX and was just about to order it when I read through some comments that this AirPort Card won't fit into my Mac at all. So I went on with a BT 4.0 USB dongle, because of the recommended Broadcom chipset, I chose the Asus BT400 dongle.

2. Activate AirDrop:
And thats already where the problems began. @jackluke 's instructions are clear, but sadly there are no patched drivers for MacBookPro7,1 avaiable. With searching in this specific example for changes he made to the drivers and afterwards trying to patch them on my own, it resulted in a kernel panic, but before I was able to modify the AirPortBrcm4360 with my board-id and card type without an issue. It always fails when I delete the Brcm4331 driver, I don't know if i patched it right or so (certainly not, related to my experience), but at that point, I searched for other solutions. And found some: someone in this thread already asked @jackluke for drivers for my Mac. His response was ... crushing? But further on there was another post, that things could work with Yosemite drivers. The risk of kernel panics is not that important for me because I am doing everything on a isolated system. After another hour of installing Yosemite, I thought before I proceed with editing files on my own, I tried the CAT tool and wow, it worked! Airdrop, Continuity features, everything was working properly. The only problem was, Yosemite is also 7 years old and Catalina would be nicer. So I backed up the Yosemite drivers and returned to a fresh Catalina and simply dragged and dropped the Yosemite drivers into catalina, restoring permissions and rebooted. Kernel Crash. As I was just about repatching the drivers out of the recovery mode, the mac booted at the second attempt and AirDrop worked on Catalina! From Mac to Mac and from Mac to iPhone as well as from iPhone to Mac. But it is very instable. A kernel crash at every boot is not that comftable, I have attached all the drivers/files/logs, maybe someone can help? I highly suspect the IO80211FamilyV2.kext, because I havn't have done anything to it as it doesn't exist in Yosemite. But I don't even know what this driver is for so it can be hardware limitations or the old drivers as well, I am not sure. From the kernel crash it seems to be the IO80211Family.kext so the old driver from Yosemite.

3. Continuity:
To enable Continuity I would proceed with @jackluke 's own Continuity Fix script and afterwards insert his patched BluetoothFamily file to whitelist the dongle. But I don't want to do that yet as the AirDrop patch is still too instable.

To sum it up, does anyone know how to fix this kernel crash, or is there another safer way to activate AirDrop on my Mac, maybe the same way @jackluke did for the other machines? I don't know how to patch that on my own, but it seems that to do so you'll need the following information:

JavaScript:
ioreg -l | grep "board-id" | awk '{print $4}'
>>> <"Mac-F222BEC8">
ioreg -r -n ARPT | grep IOName
>>> "IOName" = "pci14e4,432b"
system_profiler -detailLevel mini | grep "Card Type"
>>> 2021-04-04 20:14:46.341 system_profiler[1231:24512] SPUSBDevice: IOCreatePlugInInterfaceForService failed 0xe00002be
>>> 2021-04-04 20:14:46.352 system_profiler[1231:24512] SPUSBDevice: IOCreatePlugInInterfaceForService failed 0xe00002be
>>> Card Type: AirPort Extreme (0x14E4, 0x8D)
system_profiler -detailLevel basic | grep "Model Identifier"
>>> Model Identifier: MacBookPro7,1
>>> 2021-04-04 20:19:16.302 system_profiler[1274:25961] SPUSBDevice: IOCreatePlugInInterfaceForService failed 0xe00002be
>>> 2021-04-04 20:19:16.312 system_profiler[1274:25961] SPUSBDevice: IOCreatePlugInInterfaceForService failed 0xe00002be

Attached are the files before the patch and after, the IO80211Family.kext is patched under Yosemite by the CAT tool and has simply been inserted into Catalina. The IO80211FamilyV2.kext is out of the driver kit by @jackluke , I've compared some of them and came to the conclusion that they are the same and not model specific so that they can be used in any Catalina installation. Also attached is the Kernel Crash Log, maybe that can be fixed by further modifying the patched Yosemite driver as the unpatched one works without Kernel Crashs in Catalina as well (I only tried that once but that can be wrong as well). The screenshot is from the current test version of catalina (very unstable!) but AirDrop works, I havn't tried Continuity out but that should theoretically work as well (I installed the modified file by @jackluke and ran his continuity fix script but havn't logged me in with my Apple ID as I firstly want to get Airdrop better working.

Thanks very much if you read till here, if you can help, a lot more thanks because I am now at a point where I don't know how to continue as I don't have experience. If you need something, just ask :)
 

Attachments

  • Original Catalina Driver (Fresh Installation).zip
    11.4 MB · Views: 77
  • Patched Driver, Mixed from Yosemite and Catalina (Jackluke).zip
    7.6 MB · Views: 73
  • Kernel Crash after Patch.txt
    5.5 KB · Views: 111
  • Screenshot.png
    Screenshot.png
    1.8 MB · Views: 169
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.