Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.

davemp88

macrumors regular
Dec 13, 2020
105
19
so then would anyone suggest updating to either Big Sur 11.6.1 or Monterey Beta 8? Or just stay at the stable Big Sur 11.6 release until the final release of macOS Monterey?
 

tn-xyz

macrumors regular
Sep 13, 2017
175
211
You misunderstand, he/she has a screenshot of System report, that means he/she already has, or installed the patch.
My "Huh" in the comment was completely right.
dude, they asked if their mac/gpu supported metal and i answered. stop interpreting posts the way it suits you as you have been doing for the last several pages and start reading what has been actually written.
 

rehkram

macrumors 6502a
May 7, 2018
856
1,193
upstate NY
????

But then again, it's actually quite smart, better than sticking tape onto the display, maybe an idea for an invention.;)
It might be a "pump and dump" scheme. I have shares in Home Depot, who cleverly designed the pencil to roll off your workbench several times a day. I got tired of picking it up off the floor. It works great for this purpose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hvds

cab_007

macrumors regular
Dec 11, 2020
150
203
Just following up re. rMBP10,1 Monterey beta 7, external display not working. I ran the OCLP 0.2.4 post install HD4000 patches. The OCLP process ran OK, so time to reboot.

Boot went OK for a little while then stopped. "Maybe it's running slowly or doing a backup" I thought. 45 mins elapsed so I deployed my "MacOS Boot Stall-O-Meter" ™ (a cocktail stick stuck into a pencil eraser, see attachment). I came back an hour later and the progress bar hadn't moved. Forced a power-off and restarted. Same thing, same place (I'd left the pointer in place so I know).

Next step is Recovery Mode :)
I had that occur once and performed a power down, option-key powered up, booted up to OCLP EFI and then let it boot normally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rehkram

rehkram

macrumors 6502a
May 7, 2018
856
1,193
upstate NY
Thanks for that cab_007, no joy though. Option-booted into OCLP EFI, selected the beta volume, hung at the same point. I did that twice, then tried a normal boot to the beta volume without the option key, same thing.

Powered off again and rebooted to the Big Sur volume on my SSD, BS booted normally. Feels like a bug in Monterey beta 7 to me.
 

laertemeira

macrumors member
Jul 11, 2016
78
51
Sao Paulo, Brazil
Hello my friends. I had installed Big Sur 11.6 using OCLP 0.3.0 in my cMP5,1 (2009), but the machine was freezing after some minutes of use. So I returned to Catalina using dosdude1 patcher. Maybe Monterey B8 would be a better choice than Big Sur 11.6? The machine runs perfectly with Catalina 10.15.7, so I don't believe in hardware problems as a cause of Big Sur didn't run...
 

Adamscomputerrepair

macrumors 6502a
Aug 9, 2015
549
287
Ok update on the 09 Mac Pro. Keep in mind I’ve used OCLP 0.2.5 and 0.3.0 both and they both act the same.

When I make an installer (Big Sur or Monterey,) the installer either gets through the first half and then can’t verify my firmware, or crashes on boot.


When carbon cloning from a supported Mac and then patching with OCLP, the hard disk is completely unreadable. Like won’t even boot.

Im at wits end. Bout to say screw it and stick with Catalina but I hated it when it came out. What am I doing wrong?
 

0134168

Cancelled
May 21, 2009
2,964
2,805
Hello my friends. I had installed Big Sur 11.6 using OCLP 0.3.0 in my cMP5,1 (2009), but the machine was freezing after some minutes of use. So I returned to Catalina using dosdude1 patcher. Maybe Monterey B8 would be a better choice than Big Sur 11.6? The machine runs perfectly with Catalina 10.15.7, so I don't believe in hardware problems as a cause of Big Sur didn't run...
Big Sur 11.6 runs like a charm in Mac Pro 5,1. Monterey beta 6 also. Beta 8 is very problematic.
 

justperry

macrumors G5
Aug 10, 2007
12,631
9,967
I'm a rolling stone.
Thanks for that cab_007, no joy though. Option-booted into OCLP EFI, selected the beta volume, hung at the same point. I did that twice, then tried a normal boot to the beta volume without the option key, same thing.

Powered off again and rebooted to the Big Sur volume on my SSD, BS booted normally. Feels like a bug in Monterey beta 7 to me.
Believe it or not, a shutdown is different than a restart, I had the same happen to me, I restarted, held the Option key, this did not work, a complete shutdown and then the Option key did.....happened twice, so there must be a difference, I suspect OCLP might be the issue here.

A restart/reboot different from a shutdown, something I would have never expected to be the case.

Note: There's more to it, this was just a short explanation of what happened, problems with bootpicker and so on.
 

rehkram

macrumors 6502a
May 7, 2018
856
1,193
upstate NY
Believe it or not, a shutdown is different than a restart, I had the same happen to me, I restarted, held the Option key, this did not work, a complete shutdown and then the Option key did.....happened twice, so there must be a difference, I suspect OCLP might be the issue here.

A restart/reboot different from a shutdown, something I would have never expected to be the case.

Note: There's more to it, this was just a short explanation of what happened, problems with bootpicker and so on.

You are definitely correct, and I would like to understand the differences between a cold boot and a reboot. In my testing yesterday the only way to get out of the boot hangs was to force power down each time.
 

K two

macrumors 68020
Dec 6, 2018
2,314
3,187
North America
You are definitely correct, and I would like to understand the differences between a cold boot and a reboot. In my testing yesterday the only way to get out of the boot hangs was to force power down each time.

Booting OpenCore and macOS​


Now we finally get to boot OpenCore!


Reboot machine while holding Option to select the EFI Boot entry with the OpenCore icon (holding the Control key will make this the default boot entry):


  • This will be the Mac Boot Picker
From the OCLP site. :rolleyes:
 

rehkram

macrumors 6502a
May 7, 2018
856
1,193
upstate NY
Thanks K2, I have read all the OCLP documentation and review it for updates fairly often. That was not what I was wondering about. My interest is in understanding the differences between a cold boot and a warm boot (regardless of OCLP) in order to better understand the system flow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: justperry and K two

amaze1499

macrumors 65816
Oct 16, 2014
1,194
1,221
After a couple of days with 21A5534d on MBP9,2 16GB Ram:

Up until now pretty much each build was snappy, easy to use. This one a different story: It become literally unusable.

Bluetooth audio stuttering, mouse comes on goes away literally 10 times a minute, copy rates between internal sdds became horribly slow. Safari is a nightmare. Takes up huge amounts of RAM without having even a page open. Sometimes the whole system seems to freeze up for minutes.

This build is definitely not ready for prime time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: K two

David403

macrumors regular
Nov 5, 2017
145
136
USA
After a couple of days with 21A5534d on MBP9,2 16GB Ram:

Up until now pretty much each build was snappy, easy to use. This one a different story: It become literally unusable.

Bluetooth audio stuttering, mouse comes on goes away literally 10 times a minute, copy rates between internal sdds became horribly slow. Safari is a nightmare. Takes up huge amounts of RAM without having even a page open. Sometimes the whole system seems to freeze up for minutes.

This build is definitely not ready for prime time.
Not with me: my 5,1 on beta 8 (specs below and with SurPlus) is running fine. No problems at all Booting warm or cold and running apps.
 
Last edited:

davemp88

macrumors regular
Dec 13, 2020
105
19
all i know is with my MBP 9,2, Monterey Beta 7 was SIGNIFICANTLY slower than Big Sur 11.6.1. I'd rather just wait for the full release of Monterey and do an OTA update to that with the proper kext patching if necessary
 
  • Like
Reactions: K two

laertemeira

macrumors member
Jul 11, 2016
78
51
Sao Paulo, Brazil
Big Sur 11.6 runs like a charm in Mac Pro 5,1. Monterey beta 6 also. Beta 8 is very problematic.

Thank you @trifero!
Maybe my error was erasing the SSD as APFS volume before installing? I would format as macOS Extended (HFS+) with a GUID partition map...? Or maybe SIP was enabled? Or both... Idk... I will try to install Big Sur 11.6 in a couple weeks or wait for Monterey final release when it comes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gw463

K two

macrumors 68020
Dec 6, 2018
2,314
3,187
North America
  • Like
Reactions: rehkram

rehkram

macrumors 6502a
May 7, 2018
856
1,193
upstate NY
  • Like
Reactions: K two

cab_007

macrumors regular
Dec 11, 2020
150
203
Thanks for that cab_007, no joy though. Option-booted into OCLP EFI, selected the beta volume, hung at the same point. I did that twice, then tried a normal boot to the beta volume without the option key, same thing.

Powered off again and rebooted to the Big Sur volume on my SSD, BS booted normally. Feels like a bug in Monterey beta 7 to me.
You may want to attempt a Disk First Aid on your Monterey volumes before attempting to boot from there. You can also do a full B8 reinstall. I had lots of problems pre-OCLP 0.2.5 and the malformed B7 installer. So far, B8 has been nice on my 10,1 with post-install patch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rehkram

Bravo2zero

macrumors regular
Jun 1, 2013
125
42
Sheffield
I had to remove OS12 from the 9,1 iMac as it started to go into a standby loop where it kept going to add password Lock Screen then major lag then lock screen again. I've now dropped it back to Big Sur which works perfectly.
 

Stratus Fear

macrumors 6502a
Jan 21, 2008
696
433
Atlanta, GA
I ran into this too on the 11,3.

What the problem seems to be:
The NVIDIA dGPU is somehow preventing rendering to the display if the drivers are missing (as they are in b7)

What I did to work around this:
I did notice that the keyboard appeared responsive when the machine appeared stuck halfway through loading (caps lock would turn on, keyboard backlighting lit up when keys pressed) so on a hunch I assumed that macOS actually booted and logged in, so I grabbed my phone and connected to the machine with a VNC client, and sure enough, there was my desktop. From there I just ran the latest OCLP nightly to run the post-install patch for NVIDIA Kepler graphics and rebooted, and everything came up properly after reboot. Of course you would need screen sharing enabled to do this.

Obviously not everyone is going to conveniently have screen sharing enabled prior and a second device on hand. I can’t speak to whether OCLP can be run from recovery mode in the same manner to patch the root volume, but maybe that’s a possibility as well.
As an update to this, which I tried when installing b8. Hit the same problem where the desktop would never display, verified again that the OS was actually running by logging in with screen sharing. Another workaround, provided you have Windows installed with Boot Camp, is booting into Windows and switching the gmux chip forcefully to the iGPU using the scripts from this GitHub repo: https://github.com/0xbb/gpu-switch Rebooting (graphics will work fine via the iGPU), and then doing the post-install patches.

Upon further investigation, it appears without the Kepler kexts installed, the gmux defaults to dGPU when booting Monterey, and without the kexts, the display isn't correctly detected (macOS thinks an external display is connected to the dGPU). This would explain the lack of graphics output after update. It may be possible to use gfxCardStatus to flip to iGPU in macOS before updating as well but as far as I can tell it doesn't work on Monterey. I also am not sure if compiling gpu-switch from the above repo for macOS will work either; the readme on the repo seems to indicate it hasn't worked since Sierra. However, I have not tried it.

Edit: gfxCardStatus appears to work, provided its used while Kepler kexts are installed. So try forcing it to iGPU before running an update, in order to be able to boot and install the post-install root volume patches. It won't work while the system thinks an external display is plugged in.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tronstar and TigerA

rehkram

macrumors 6502a
May 7, 2018
856
1,193
upstate NY
You may want to attempt a Disk First Aid on your Monterey volumes before attempting to boot from there. You can also do a full B8 reinstall. I had lots of problems pre-OCLP 0.2.5 and the malformed B7 installer. So far, B8 has been nice on my 10,1 with post-install patch.

After some consideration I've decided to wait until Apple have all their ducks in a row and release another beta with fixes to the known problems. I don't think it's worth the time debugging problems that should disappear in the next release. I can live without having a slightly broken beta to play with.

I did run first aid on both volumes from Big Sur. Problems found included a corrupt snapshot which will "disappear when the snapshot is deleted" :) and a couple of other warm fuzzy messages. Ended with exit code 0, which probably means "don't worry about a thing"
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: cab_007
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.