If you took the fruit logo off the back of the iPhone 5, and put a little green Droid. That 4" phone would be ridiculed like no other as the outdated sad design it is, with a home screen that looks like you left the app drawer open.
I really think the big bezel on top and bottom is very dated looking. The iPhone bezel takes up so much space. New phones like the S4 are almost edge to edge all screen.
iPhone 5 looks like old tube TV with big wooden box it sits in. New Android phones look like the nice thin Plasma HDTV's.
Nice assessment. I most definetly agree. Not that I enjoy acknowledging the oddities of iPhone 5. If I didn't know Apple so well it wouldn't be so annoying.
When one has a long enjoyable (read many years) experience with Apple, only to have the 4S & 5 be so bland is out of character for Apple.
Especially since I'm not blaming the "new leader". Nor do I believe in this case, Jobs would have made one wit of difference other than his world class sales & marketing spin.