They've won numerous awards. Effie, One Show, US News' Best Video Ad, Garfield Bobby awards, etc.
What's your point? There are so many awards these days, you can win one for anything, and because there are so many their value is decreased. If it's easy to win an award, it's no longer an honor.
Apple is selling Macs in record numbers.
Apple is virtually recession-proof. Most of their revenue coming from Mac sales.
Well duh, Macs are Apple's most expensive products. Where else is there revenue going to come from? Selling 2 million iPhones probably brings in less revenue than selling 1 million Macs. Don't quote me on that, it's a wild but educated guess.
Macs, Macbooks especially, are among the most coveted and desirable tech products today.
That's because they're pretty and Apple has a good reputation. If Vista didn't have such a horrible reputation, the general public's opinion of Windows wouldn't be so bad. And Apple's not the reason for Windows' reputation, they only push what others have said.
Apple rules the $1000+ notebook market.
That's because all of their notebooks ARE $1000+. (There is the $999.99 MacBook, but one cent under $1000 doesn't make a big difference)
If their ads aren't working, they sure as hell aren't hurting them.
I never said they're not working, by calling the ads "bad" I wasn't referring to their effectiveness, but referring to the quality of them. (Quality in this case meaning the dialogue and point)
That's YOUR opinion and you're wrong anyway. You're going to tell a company that has billions of available cash in the bank, who's retail stores are doing quite well despite the decline in the economy, who's computer's (which are the underdog) market share is growing rapidly and who's online app store is the largest in the industry and is making crazy profits, that their ads are bad and a tired out joke? I think Apple know's their business a whole lot better than you do buddy. If it wasn't working they wouldn't be showing those same tired of joke ads.
By definition, there is no such thing as a "wrong" opinion. If you don't accept that
fact then I wouldn't have a need to address your post.
Anyways, I don't see why you are even mentioning the App Store or retail stores, because these ads have nothing to do with them. Is Apple making money? Yes. Is it because of the Get-a-Mac ads? Not necessarily. Word of mouth is a powerful marketing tool as well, and that's the reason most people
I know are interested in Macs, if they have any interest at all. It is not because Apple says "Macs are speedy and virus-free," it's because they've heard about Macs from other people with good experiences, or have had an especially bad experience with Windows. That may be a very, very slim fraction of the population, but it is still a fraction.
Personally, I find the ads repulsive. It's this that gives Mac users a reputation as being stuck up and pretentious. And that's not something I want to be associated with. Even look through this thread, even the biggest Apple fanboys are admitting that these ads are old, and to but it bluntly, stupid. Anyways, the reason why
I like Macs is because of the gorgeous, sturdy construction. But I couldn't care less about their software. There are several Macs in my household, I've used OS X a good amount, and I don't like it very much.