Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

JT2002TJ

macrumors 68020
Nov 7, 2013
2,068
1,397
Any car that isn't a skateboard platform ;) It is just an inherent trait of the design choice of the platform. It is not an opinion, it is just the way it is.

I just showed the picture of my e46 vs my M3... There is no significant difference in foot to waist height in the back seats. So clearly, it is your opinion...
 

The-Real-Deal82

macrumors P6
Jan 17, 2013
17,314
25,463
Wales, United Kingdom
Tesla cars are definitely a great choice if you're looking for an EV! They offer a lot of features that make them stand out compared to other brands.

Tesla are certainly impressive in terms of tech and features and I won’t deny they are instrumental in pushing other manufacturers to innovate faster. They are very bland in terms of aesthetics though and remind me of the Prius craze 20 odd years ago. When you compare their design against Europe styled cars, they don’t compare for me.
 

cyb3rdud3

macrumors 601
Jun 22, 2014
4,081
2,751
UK
What are the UK prices of the same vehicles I listed?
Can't get current prices online anymore. Tesla doesn't allow for Model S orders at the moment, just a deposit for when it may become available again. So it has become academic only.

They do still do Model 3 & Y, and they are keenly priced, but I'll have an BMW i4 for £5k more anyday. A much better experience, and much more pleasant cabin to be in, in my opinion. Or even just a BMW 3 series 320i entry level. Similar performance, cheaper, and a more pleasant package to be in. Or if you want electric at the same price; a Polestar 2 base level is same price as a Tesla Model 3 but a much more pleasant environment build to a higher standard to be in. And even got a binnacle :) Tesla likely will either drop their prices further to match the segment their cars belong in, or (more likely) will keep them at this level for longer whilst others become more expensive.

For me personally I wish they were truly playing the luxury segment other than cost of the Model S/X as that is where I'm shopping next for myself. I just don't think they can match the competition other than exceed on speed from a the plaid model.
 

cyb3rdud3

macrumors 601
Jun 22, 2014
4,081
2,751
UK
I just showed the picture of my e46 vs my M3... There is no significant difference in foot to waist height in the back seats. So clearly, it is your opinion...
Measure it, you'll notice a difference. Think about it logically, where do the batteries go? And if the batteries are there then where do the feet go? You can see it in the shape of the floor.

Anyway we clearly experience it, it is noticeable, but granted perhaps less when people have short legs.
 

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
56,993
56,015
Behind the Lens, UK
Tesla are certainly impressive in terms of tech and features and I won’t deny they are instrumental in pushing other manufacturers to innovate faster. They are very bland in terms of aesthetics though and remind me of the Prius craze 20 odd years ago. When you compare their design against Europe styled cars, they don’t compare for me.
Same here. The design just leaves me cold. I think the batteries are great. The charging network is great. The way the car communicates with the charger is great. They got all that spot on.
They just need to employ some European design team and QC for their next models.
 

mittencuh

macrumors regular
Nov 4, 2012
146
192
Colorado Springs
I'm not sure everyone is giving Tesla a fair shot. If you look at each comparative model, in the luxury space, the other manufacture's vehicles cost WAY more.

MB S500 starts at $114k the S580 starts at $124k
Audi A8 starts at $90k the S8 starts at $121k
740i starts at $96k the M7 starts at $?k not listed in the US

Even the midsized RS/M/AMG are in the price range of the S Plaid.

The pricing of vehicles have significantly increased over the past 10-15 years.
You're comparing the Model S to the class above it. There is no way a Model S is competitive with a large executive sedan. It's much closer to the E-class/A6/5er/EQE in size.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyb3rdud3

xaqt93

macrumors 6502a
Jun 17, 2011
517
440
I personally have a Nissan Leaf and I love the thing. I was looking at getting a Tesla, but I will be honest, I did not get it because at the time, they did not have support for Apple Music and they did not have Apple Car Play. Anyway, I love my car. I recently went in to upgrade my leaf to something better, and found out that my car is worth more than what I owe, and decided to keep it.
 

JT2002TJ

macrumors 68020
Nov 7, 2013
2,068
1,397
Same here. The design just leaves me cold. I think the batteries are great. The charging network is great. The way the car communicates with the charger is great. They got all that spot on.
They just need to employ some European design team and QC for their next models.

I like the interior look... Simple, clean, not cluttered. I do think a small screen behind the steering wheel with the main details could be included in the M3/MY lineup, much like the MS/MX.

I'm not a fan of the snub nose on the M3/MY, I like the look of the aftermarket front bumpers that have that bumper line straight across, but I as I understand it, every aspect of the exterior design was for efficiency.

I also will say, that if you are not in the FSD beta program, the interface is not the best. I've been in the Beta program since I bought my M3. So, perhaps the big issue a lot of people have with the Tesla "OS" is that. The next software upgrade should bring most of the FSD Beta features to the regular OS.

For example, FSD Beta has this:
JSuXKMt.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: QCassidy352

JT2002TJ

macrumors 68020
Nov 7, 2013
2,068
1,397
You're comparing the Model S to the class above it. There is no way a Model S is competitive with a large executive sedan. It's much closer to the E-class/A6/5er/EQE in size.
The M3/MY are mid-size sedans, the MS/MX are full size sedans... The S is in the same class as the S/A8/7 series. Although it may be shorter (because of no need for an ICE), it is wider than the A8 and S550. The interior is the size of the full-sized sedans, and the interior of the M3/MY are the size of mid-sized sedans.

My M3 has a much bigger interior than my previous 3 series, and my wife's current A4. The interior is the about the same size as an A6/5-series.

There are no 3 series/A4/C-class where I can fit in the back seat (at 6'2") with even an average size adult in the front. You can see in the pictures I posted. The 3 series is with the driver's seat where I sit, the same is true for my M3.

I pay attention to this because I have a 17 month old, with a rear facing car seat. In the 3 series/A4, I can't even get in the car in front of the car seat. I have plenty of room in my M3.
 

JT2002TJ

macrumors 68020
Nov 7, 2013
2,068
1,397
I personally have a Nissan Leaf and I love the thing. I was looking at getting a Tesla, but I will be honest, I did not get it because at the time, they did not have support for Apple Music and they did not have Apple Car Play. Anyway, I love my car. I recently went in to upgrade my leaf to something better, and found out that my car is worth more than what I owe, and decided to keep it.

This is still the case. I believe Tesla doesn't want to pay the license fee for Apple's CarPlay. The M3/MY also do not have Sirius XM. The MS/MX I believe either used to or still do have a module.

I agree it is a HUGE flaw, BUT, after having the car for 2 months, I have adapted. I run Waze on my phone and have it connected via Bluetooth, so I get the notifications, I also play SXM via my phone. Playing SXM via my phone saves me money too, but you do have to interact with the phone to select channels...

I will say that Tesla's maps run better than anything interfaced though CarPlay that I have experienced yet. The ability to quickly pinch to zoom, without losing the rendering, and overlay satellite view without slowing down is amazing. I'm still not sure if I like Waze's routing better than Telsa's because I haven't gone on any trips out of my "comfort zone" yet.

Also, if you use FSD, the car is going to use the car's maps anyways, I'm not sure there is a way for manufacturers to use the phone's maps for controlling the vehicle. I use Autopilot/FSD Beta 90%+ of my driving. It works really well in the NY/Long Island area.

Text messages are read to you and send messages via Tesla's software, you can also read any current messages that come in. So, they have created an adequate workaround to keep you in their UI.
 

cyb3rdud3

macrumors 601
Jun 22, 2014
4,081
2,751
UK
The M3/MY are mid-size sedans, the MS/MX are full size sedans... The S is in the same class as the S/A8/7 series. Although it may be shorter (because of no need for an ICE), it is wider than the A8 and S550. The interior is the size of the full-sized sedans, and the interior of the M3/MY are the size of mid-sized sedans.
It may be size wise but it isn't luxury wise which becomes really important when you are looking in that top end class. That is saying like a Toyota Camry with heater leather seats is like an Mercedes S Class. All sorts of subjective elements come into it like the materials used, ownership experience, experience when driving and being driven. It is something Tesla just hasn't mastered, even Lexus hasn't mastered that despite almost doing it on paper to perfection. That class comes with an x-factor for lack of a better word. Or as I would say; je ne sais quoi.

My M3 has a much bigger interior than my previous 3 series, and my wife's current A4. The interior is the about the same size as an A6/5-series.
No it isn't. 🤣
There are no 3 series/A4/C-class where I can fit in the back seat (at 6'2") with even an average size adult in the front. You can see in the pictures I posted. The 3 series is with the driver's seat where I sit, the same is true for my M3.

I pay attention to this because I have a 17 month old, with a rear facing car seat. In the 3 series/A4, I can't even get in the car in front of the car seat. I have plenty of room in my M3.
A more practical interior for your particular use case perhaps, but much bigger and the same as an a6/5-series; nope just nope. Skoda is also very good at practical interiors in smaller sizes, and Seat tends to be as well. And Nissan used to be pretty good at that as well. And there is nothing wrong with that if that is what is desired, but don't correlate that to being bigger.

People just want different things; and with little ones on tow there are special needs. I never forgot that when ours were little a VW Touareq was 'too small' aka impractical as a stroller couldn't fit in the boot unless put in diagonal. The boot was measurably not smaller, it was just impractical for that use. Yet in a VW Golf it did fit because it had some recesses.
 

cyb3rdud3

macrumors 601
Jun 22, 2014
4,081
2,751
UK
I personally have a Nissan Leaf and I love the thing. I was looking at getting a Tesla, but I will be honest, I did not get it because at the time, they did not have support for Apple Music and they did not have Apple Car Play. Anyway, I love my car. I recently went in to upgrade my leaf to something better, and found out that my car is worth more than what I owe, and decided to keep it.
Ours runs on Android Automotive Operating System AAOS. At first there was no Apple Carplay, last June that was introduced. I actually haven't used it as all the inbuilt systems work incredibly well together with an iPhone and nicely integrated. Locations search on the iPhone also show up in the car, Google Assistant can easily deal with iMessage (which is SMS anyway) both reading out and dictating and sending. Inbuild for Spotify (or if you prefer Deezer, Youtube, Amazon etc). I thought I would miss it, but nope not at all actually.

Inbuilt system can run really well, they aren't all the old archaic ICE systems anymore.
 

The-Real-Deal82

macrumors P6
Jan 17, 2013
17,314
25,463
Wales, United Kingdom
There are no 3 series/A4/C-class where I can fit in the back seat (at 6'2") with even an average size adult in the front. You can see in the pictures I posted. The 3 series is with the driver's seat where I sit, the same is true for my M3.
I can get a 6’2” adult behind me in my Audi A4 quite comfortably. The older BMW 3-Series have a slightly smaller cabin, or that’s how it feels.

This is mine:
936fed9a869c1cac79f59170c1fe9207.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyb3rdud3

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
56,993
56,015
Behind the Lens, UK
I like the interior look... Simple, clean, not cluttered. I do think a small screen behind the steering wheel with the main details could be included in the M3/MY lineup, much like the MS/MX.

I'm not a fan of the snub nose on the M3/MY, I like the look of the aftermarket front bumpers that have that bumper line straight across, but I as I understand it, every aspect of the exterior design was for efficiency.

I also will say, that if you are not in the FSD beta program, the interface is not the best. I've been in the Beta program since I bought my M3. So, perhaps the big issue a lot of people have with the Tesla "OS" is that. The next software upgrade should bring most of the FSD Beta features to the regular OS.

For example, FSD Beta has this:
JSuXKMt.jpg
Everyone is different and likes different things. But to me it just looks like someone glued an iPad to the dash.
Touch screens are also not great in a moving car.
 

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
56,993
56,015
Behind the Lens, UK
This is still the case. I believe Tesla doesn't want to pay the license fee for Apple's CarPlay. The M3/MY also do not have Sirius XM. The MS/MX I believe either used to or still do have a module.

I agree it is a HUGE flaw, BUT, after having the car for 2 months, I have adapted. I run Waze on my phone and have it connected via Bluetooth, so I get the notifications, I also play SXM via my phone. Playing SXM via my phone saves me money too, but you do have to interact with the phone to select channels...

I will say that Tesla's maps run better than anything interfaced though CarPlay that I have experienced yet. The ability to quickly pinch to zoom, without losing the rendering, and overlay satellite view without slowing down is amazing. I'm still not sure if I like Waze's routing better than Telsa's because I haven't gone on any trips out of my "comfort zone" yet.

Also, if you use FSD, the car is going to use the car's maps anyways, I'm not sure there is a way for manufacturers to use the phone's maps for controlling the vehicle. I use Autopilot/FSD Beta 90%+ of my driving. It works really well in the NY/Long Island area.

Text messages are read to you and send messages via Tesla's software, you can also read any current messages that come in. So, they have created an adequate workaround to keep you in their UI.
No CarPlay is a deal breaker for me on any car I would consider. I didn’t have it on my Golf and it frustrated the hell out of me. Hopefully they get it on there at some point. I think they would get some more customers if they did.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Tagbert

cyb3rdud3

macrumors 601
Jun 22, 2014
4,081
2,751
UK
I can get a 6’2” adult behind me in my Audi A4 quite comfortably. The older BMW 3-Series have a slightly smaller cabin, or that’s how it feels.
That is exactly it! Less flat floor, less flat bench, less flat seats, less flat dashboard, it's an illusion that it is smaller. It isn't really, it just more ergonomic, hugs more, and different. No right or wrong about it, it is what it is and people have different preferences or needs.
 

The-Real-Deal82

macrumors P6
Jan 17, 2013
17,314
25,463
Wales, United Kingdom
Everyone is different and likes different things. But to me it just looks like someone glued an iPad to the dash.
Touch screens are also not great in a moving car.
Its mad isn't it, you can get 3 points on your license and a significant fine for touching a smartphone mounted on your dashboard, but its fine navigating through a tablet that is integrated into the car. I agree with so many car reviewers that these almost fully touchscreen dashboards are dangerous and distracting. Features like heaters and air vent speeds should not be hidden in menus and physical buttons should be mandatory on this sort of thing. I think perhaps we'll see these features comoing back to mechanical buttons and knobs over the next few years as its being flagged up a lot in the motoring press. My wifes car is awful for this and one of the reasons she is keen to change it again soon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SalisburySam

diamond.g

macrumors G4
Mar 20, 2007
11,438
2,663
OBX
Can't even open the glovebox without pressing a 'button' on the touch screen. It is so silly.
So I have conflicting thoughts about this. I don't like that it isn't able to be opened without touching the screen. On the other hand I do like that with valet mode it is locked and that you can set a pin to prevent it from being opened when the vehicle isn't in valet mode.
 

JT2002TJ

macrumors 68020
Nov 7, 2013
2,068
1,397
It may be size wise but it isn't luxury wise which becomes really important when you are looking in that top end class. That is saying like a Toyota Camry with heater leather seats is like an Mercedes S Class. All sorts of subjective elements come into it like the materials used, ownership experience, experience when driving and being driven. It is something Tesla just hasn't mastered, even Lexus hasn't mastered that despite almost doing it on paper to perfection. That class comes with an x-factor for lack of a better word. Or as I would say; je ne sais quoi.

The size conversation is in reference to racing on the track... I asked what other full sized vehicles were on the list of top finishers on the Nürburgring ring. The fact that a full sized vehicle is hanging with stripped down race cars shows just how fast it actually is, even around corners.

No it isn't. 🤣

It is. The back seats of the mid sized sedans, measure from back of front seat to front of rear bench is much bigger than that of the smaller 3/C/A4 (measure with the front seats all the way back).

A more practical interior for your particular use case perhaps, but much bigger and the same as an a6/5-series; nope just nope. Skoda is also very good at practical interiors in smaller sizes, and Seat tends to be as well. And Nissan used to be pretty good at that as well. And there is nothing wrong with that if that is what is desired, but don't correlate that to being bigger.

People just want different things; and with little ones on tow there are special needs. I never forgot that when ours were little a VW Touareq was 'too small' aka impractical as a stroller couldn't fit in the boot unless put in diagonal. The boot was measurably not smaller, it was just impractical for that use. Yet in a VW Golf it did fit because it had some recesses.

Please reread what you quoted. I said it is much bigger than the A4/3 series, and it is the SAME SIZE as the A6/5 series. I never said it was bigger than the A6/5 series...
 

JT2002TJ

macrumors 68020
Nov 7, 2013
2,068
1,397
I can get a 6’2” adult behind me in my Audi A4 quite comfortably. The older BMW 3-Series have a slightly smaller cabin, or that’s how it feels.

This is mine:
936fed9a869c1cac79f59170c1fe9207.jpg

How tall are you, is your driver's seat all the way back? The difference between an A6 and an A4 or the 3 and 5 is a few inches, maybe 4" (between seats).

Either way, My driver's seat is all the way back and clearly there is more distance between the drivers seat back and the rear seat front.

 

cyb3rdud3

macrumors 601
Jun 22, 2014
4,081
2,751
UK
So I have conflicting thoughts about this. I don't like that it isn't able to be opened without touching the screen. On the other hand I do like that with valet mode it is locked and that you can set a pin to prevent it from being opened when the vehicle isn't in valet mode.
Agreed, I think a good compromise would have been a physical button/latch that doesn't work with a valet key. My Range Rover does that.
 

JT2002TJ

macrumors 68020
Nov 7, 2013
2,068
1,397
No CarPlay is a deal breaker for me on any car I would consider. I didn’t have it on my Golf and it frustrated the hell out of me. Hopefully they get it on there at some point. I think they would get some more customers if they did.

I get this. I swore I wouldn't buy another car without Carplay, until I ended up getting this M3.

I am interested to see how Tesla would execute Carplay integration with FSD, maybe this is the second big reason they opted not to integrate it.

At least where I am, Autopilot/FSD Beta in Tesla is worlds ahead of the other manufacturers. Since I drive 3 hours a day, this was the biggest factor in my EV selection. My M3 does most of my driving during my commute.
 

cyb3rdud3

macrumors 601
Jun 22, 2014
4,081
2,751
UK
Please reread what you quoted. I said it is much bigger than the A4/3 series, and it is the SAME SIZE as the A6/5 series. I never said it was bigger than the A6/5 series...
That is what I'm saying as well. The bigger part referred to the aforementioned A4/3 series and the same size to the A6/5 series ;)

Blimey this is turning into a vanity fair ;)
 

JT2002TJ

macrumors 68020
Nov 7, 2013
2,068
1,397
So I have conflicting thoughts about this. I don't like that it isn't able to be opened without touching the screen. On the other hand I do like that with valet mode it is locked and that you can set a pin to prevent it from being opened when the vehicle isn't in valet mode.

Tesla has done a great job of having voice commands. And since the USB recording device was moved to the glove box, it was a good move by them. I get the want for physical buttons, but I have not missed them. I can control everything via voice commands, without moving my hand from the steering wheel.

 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.